1 00:00:00,150 --> 00:00:03,341 In October 2024, the month before the election, 2 00:00:03,541 --> 00:00:06,162 the CEO of Stanley Black Decker, 3 00:00:06,312 --> 00:00:11,174 Donald Allen Jr., told shareholders the company was getting ready for possible 4 00:00:11,174 --> 00:00:15,686 Trump tariffs. Stanley Black Decker is the Connecticut company behind DeWalt, 5 00:00:15,836 --> 00:00:17,936 the Yellow Power Tools. A month later, 6 00:00:17,936 --> 00:00:21,927 in November 2024, the company sent consumers a letter. 7 00:00:22,077 --> 00:00:26,718 It said tariff actions expected from the incoming administration would require 8 00:00:26,899 --> 00:00:27,899 price increases. 9 00:00:27,949 --> 00:00:30,139 Expected. Trump hadn't been sworn in yet. 10 00:00:30,289 --> 00:00:32,490 The price increases were already in the mail. 11 00:00:32,640 --> 00:00:34,501 Then the tariff showed up for real. 12 00:00:34,541 --> 00:00:39,574 In April 2025, Stanley Black and Decker raised prices by what it called a high 13 00:00:39,574 --> 00:00:42,935 single digit, planned another increase for the fourth quarter, 14 00:00:43,176 --> 00:00:46,959 and put its tariffs hit at $800 million. 15 00:00:47,109 --> 00:00:49,470 If you bought a DeWalt Impact Wrench that year, 16 00:00:49,630 --> 00:00:53,472 the company had already told you in writing who was paying the tariff. 17 00:00:53,673 --> 00:00:54,353 You were. 18 00:00:54,353 --> 00:01:00,157 On February 20th, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the emergency law Trump 19 00:01:00,157 --> 00:01:01,717 used for his tariffs on Canada, 20 00:01:01,898 --> 00:01:06,489 Mexico, and China, and for the ones he rolled out on what he called Liberation 21 00:01:06,489 --> 00:01:10,062 Day, never gave him the power to impose tariffs at all. 22 00:01:10,212 --> 00:01:15,745 The government had collected somewhere between 166 billion and 175 billion 23 00:01:15,905 --> 00:01:17,586 it had no authority to collect. 24 00:01:17,736 --> 00:01:19,267 So it has to pay it back. 25 00:01:19,417 --> 00:01:24,633 Stanley Black and Decker is getting at least $298 million of your money. 26 00:01:25,154 --> 00:01:27,076 And when the company reported that money, 27 00:01:27,226 --> 00:01:31,651 it said it was offset by variable incentive compensation. 28 00:01:31,801 --> 00:01:32,502 Bonuses. 29 00:01:32,502 --> 00:01:35,785 It's got company, TJX, which owns TJ Maxx, 30 00:01:35,785 --> 00:01:41,509 Marshalls, and HomeGoods, they got $331 million back and set aside $112 million 31 00:01:41,509 --> 00:01:47,564 of it for bonuses. American Eagle got $196 million and booked $35 million in extra 32 00:01:47,564 --> 00:01:52,838 incentive pay. Akushnet, the company that makes tight list golf balls and foot joy, 33 00:01:53,058 --> 00:01:56,961 got $45 million and put $12 million toward bonuses. 34 00:01:57,111 --> 00:01:59,212 All of that comes from ProPublica. 35 00:01:59,362 --> 00:02:00,693 Two of the reporters, Robert, 36 00:02:00,895 --> 00:02:05,719 Fattorecci and Nick McMillan went through thousands of securities filings 37 00:02:05,719 --> 00:02:10,352 and earnings calls and found that at least nine publicly traded companies disclosed 38 00:02:10,352 --> 00:02:12,384 doing this. Their story ran yesterday. 39 00:02:12,534 --> 00:02:17,028 You paid that tariff at the register at a Marshall's in a red county or a blue 40 00:02:17,028 --> 00:02:19,710 county, and the register didn't really ask you which. 41 00:02:19,860 --> 00:02:23,403 When the money came back, it went to whoever's name was on the customs 42 00:02:23,403 --> 00:02:27,277 paperwork. At TJ Maxx, about a third of it went into the bonus pool. 43 00:02:42,416 --> 00:02:44,326 This is the Overlap. I'm Will. 44 00:02:44,476 --> 00:02:47,552 And I am Joshua and I am mad at a power tool company. 45 00:02:47,672 --> 00:02:48,672 First time for everything. 46 00:02:48,794 --> 00:02:50,743 You're gonna have to tell me what to cross off your Christmas list. 47 00:02:50,893 --> 00:02:53,865 Right. So here's the kind of the story in one sentence here, 48 00:02:53,865 --> 00:02:56,117 right? You paid the tariffs in higher prices. 49 00:02:56,338 --> 00:02:58,940 The Supreme Court said the tariffs were illegal. 50 00:02:59,090 --> 00:03:03,234 The government is paying the money back to the companies that imported those goods. 51 00:03:03,384 --> 00:03:06,356 And some of those companies are paying it out as bonuses. 52 00:03:06,506 --> 00:03:08,107 Feels like 2008 all over again. 53 00:03:08,257 --> 00:03:08,777 Um 54 00:03:08,614 --> 00:03:09,614 Yeah. 55 00:03:09,620 --> 00:03:11,422 but it all came together in the same week. 56 00:03:11,572 --> 00:03:15,075 ProPublica's story ran for November on November 16th. 57 00:03:15,225 --> 00:03:17,247 Five days before that, on November 11th, 58 00:03:17,397 --> 00:03:19,639 Senate Democrats wrote to Andrew Ferguson, 59 00:03:19,699 --> 00:03:21,421 the chairman of the Federal Trade Commission, 60 00:03:21,571 --> 00:03:25,174 which is the agency that polices unfair and deceptive trade business practices, 61 00:03:25,324 --> 00:03:29,257 and asked him to investigate companies that raised prices over tariffs and kept 62 00:03:29,257 --> 00:03:30,257 then kept the refunds. 63 00:03:30,268 --> 00:03:34,090 Th and this week the total paid out in refunds passed a hundred billion dollars. 64 00:03:34,240 --> 00:03:35,584 The money's already gone out the door. 65 00:03:35,734 --> 00:03:39,637 So by the end of this, you'll be able to explain to somebody why the check goes 66 00:03:39,637 --> 00:03:44,381 to the company when the company told you in a letter that you'd be the one paying. 67 00:03:44,531 --> 00:03:49,215 Y'all know why a bonus formula can't tell the difference between money a company 68 00:03:49,215 --> 00:03:52,117 made selling drills and money the government sent back. 69 00:03:52,518 --> 00:03:57,131 And you'll know who was offering to buy up refund claims at a discount before 70 00:03:57,131 --> 00:03:59,193 the Supreme Court ever made their ruling, 71 00:03:59,433 --> 00:04:02,716 including a firm run by the Commerce Secretary's son. 72 00:04:02,866 --> 00:04:04,117 And you'll get the company side, 73 00:04:04,117 --> 00:04:06,320 which is better than you'd expect in a couple of places. 74 00:04:06,396 --> 00:04:08,152 Uh starting with the title of this episode, 75 00:04:08,152 --> 00:04:09,690 which is a little unfair to TJ Maxx. 76 00:04:09,840 --> 00:04:14,332 A little bit. TJX says the $112 million covers, 77 00:04:14,332 --> 00:04:17,734 quote, eligible associates globally. 78 00:04:17,884 --> 00:04:21,426 So some of it, honestly, could go to people working the registers, 79 00:04:21,426 --> 00:04:27,231 but how much? TJX says it can't break that out until its fiscal year is actually 80 00:04:27,251 --> 00:04:27,781 over. 81 00:04:27,781 --> 00:04:29,784 And hopefully we've forgotten this whole thing ever happened. 82 00:04:30,646 --> 00:04:31,110 Hopefully. 83 00:04:31,045 --> 00:04:31,226 but 84 00:04:31,226 --> 00:04:32,798 it's the same, it's the same as Stanley, 85 00:04:32,798 --> 00:04:36,501 Black, and Decker. Uh the company hasn't disclosed how much of its refund went 86 00:04:36,501 --> 00:04:39,395 to bonuses or how far down the ranks those bonuses go. 87 00:04:39,545 --> 00:04:43,230 That split is the piece that hasn't been reported anywhere because the companies 88 00:04:43,230 --> 00:04:44,211 haven't put it on paper. 89 00:04:44,211 --> 00:04:46,462 And let's be honest, they probably won't, 90 00:04:46,612 --> 00:04:48,653 because the government is not filling the gap either. 91 00:04:48,803 --> 00:04:51,364 ProPublica asked for records on the refunds, 92 00:04:51,364 --> 00:04:53,676 and the Trump administration denied the request. 93 00:04:53,676 --> 00:04:59,237 So the only reason we know about these nine companies is that they're publicly 94 00:04:59,237 --> 00:05:01,438 owned companies. And with publicly owned companies, 95 00:05:01,558 --> 00:05:03,880 they have to file their finances with the SEC, 96 00:05:03,880 --> 00:05:05,300 the Securities and Exchange Commission, 97 00:05:05,300 --> 00:05:06,981 for those of you who don't have a 401. 98 00:05:07,131 --> 00:05:08,552 Customs and Border Protection, 99 00:05:08,552 --> 00:05:10,993 the agency that collects the tariffs at the border, 100 00:05:11,143 --> 00:05:15,082 Counted more than 330 million importers who paid these duties. 101 00:05:15,232 --> 00:05:17,848 ProPublica could only look at the public ones. 102 00:05:17,998 --> 00:05:20,033 So three hundred and thirty million or three hundred and thirty thousand? 103 00:05:20,183 --> 00:05:22,411 Three hundred and thirty thousand importers. 104 00:05:22,561 --> 00:05:26,663 Okay, got it. but we know that the minimum number of companies we're dealing with 105 00:05:26,663 --> 00:05:30,369 now are nine companies. And it's what you can count from the one slice of companies 106 00:05:30,369 --> 00:05:31,541 that have to show their books. 107 00:05:31,691 --> 00:05:33,564 So the story starts with a form at the border. 108 00:05:33,714 --> 00:05:36,366 Now, obviously, it doesn't really start at the border. 109 00:05:36,366 --> 00:05:39,678 These are coming in on chips, and it's all really just a big paperwork trail. 110 00:05:39,828 --> 00:05:45,103 But the Trump law that he used specifically was called the IEEEPA 111 00:05:45,103 --> 00:05:48,325 or the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. 112 00:05:48,475 --> 00:05:52,898 That lets a president take economic actions after declaring a national 113 00:05:52,898 --> 00:05:55,659 emergency, which on February 2nd, 114 00:05:55,809 --> 00:05:58,521 2025, he signed three executive orders, 115 00:05:58,521 --> 00:06:00,262 numbers 14193. 116 00:06:00,412 --> 00:06:06,887 Through 14195, using the AIPA to put tariffs on goods from Canada, 117 00:06:07,007 --> 00:06:09,539 Mexico, and China. On April 2nd, 118 00:06:09,539 --> 00:06:14,643 he announced the Liberation Day tariffs under Executive Order 14257. 119 00:06:14,983 --> 00:06:17,785 Those are the tariffs the Supreme Court actually threw out. 120 00:06:17,935 --> 00:06:20,366 A tariff is a tax on imported goods, 121 00:06:20,366 --> 00:06:23,708 very simply, and somebody has to physically write the check for those 122 00:06:23,708 --> 00:06:26,520 goods. Maybe not physically, maybe they just. 123 00:06:26,701 --> 00:06:30,602 Put it in a printer. But that's the importer of record. 124 00:06:30,752 --> 00:06:34,754 It's essentially the company whose name is actually put on that customs form that 125 00:06:34,754 --> 00:06:38,235 has to be filled out, which is the paperwork filed when a shipping company 126 00:06:38,390 --> 00:06:41,597 or a shipment of goods comes into the country. 127 00:06:41,747 --> 00:06:44,228 So the importer pays customs and border protection. 128 00:06:44,378 --> 00:06:47,509 After that, the importer decides what to do with the cost. 129 00:06:47,509 --> 00:06:52,952 It can eat that cost, it can, squeeze some of its suppliers for a lower goods price, 130 00:06:53,012 --> 00:06:53,422 or 131 00:06:53,422 --> 00:06:57,660 It can actually put it in the price that it uses to or that it gives to sell those 132 00:06:57,660 --> 00:06:58,895 goods to somebody else. 133 00:06:59,045 --> 00:07:02,397 And our good friends as Stanley Black and Decker picked door number three. 134 00:07:02,547 --> 00:07:04,768 And they announced it before the tariffs even existed, 135 00:07:04,918 --> 00:07:06,259 which is, nice heads up, at least. 136 00:07:06,409 --> 00:07:08,837 but that's where Orr Rothschild comes in. 137 00:07:08,837 --> 00:07:12,433 Uh he's in Wisconsin and he's a finance and strategy executive. 138 00:07:12,583 --> 00:07:14,344 He bought a bunch of DeWalt tools, 139 00:07:14,444 --> 00:07:16,525 a handheld blower, an impact wrench, 140 00:07:16,546 --> 00:07:17,966 a hedge trimmer, and some others. 141 00:07:18,116 --> 00:07:19,657 Got some serious work done last year. 142 00:07:20,117 --> 00:07:21,678 according to the Hartford Business Journal, 143 00:07:21,678 --> 00:07:23,289 he's now using state or sorry. 144 00:07:23,479 --> 00:07:27,301 Now suing Stanley Blackendecker in Connecticut on behalf of uh all of their 145 00:07:27,301 --> 00:07:29,893 customers. He's trying to start a putative class action. 146 00:07:29,913 --> 00:07:32,534 his argument is that the company raised prices because of tariffs. 147 00:07:32,634 --> 00:07:35,596 And so in that said so in that November 2024 letter. 148 00:07:35,746 --> 00:07:37,506 And now, in the words of his lawsuit, 149 00:07:37,656 --> 00:07:41,378 quote, stands to recover the same tariff payments twice. 150 00:07:41,528 --> 00:07:44,619 So once from him at the checkout, 151 00:07:44,619 --> 00:07:47,811 right? Like from his wallet, and then once from the government. 152 00:07:47,951 --> 00:07:50,873 And here's kind of how the second one works. 153 00:07:51,023 --> 00:07:56,075 February 20th, 2026, the Supreme Court basically decides learning resources 154 00:07:56,075 --> 00:08:01,468 versus Trump six to three. IEPA doesn't actually authorize the president to impose 155 00:08:01,468 --> 00:08:05,789 tariffs. Theoretically, the powers that are would be 156 00:08:05,929 --> 00:08:09,111 worked here in this case. We have the separate branch, 157 00:08:09,111 --> 00:08:11,282 which is the judicial branch, which rules and says, 158 00:08:11,282 --> 00:08:12,603 no, the president can't do that, 159 00:08:12,603 --> 00:08:14,903 which is theoretically what's supposed to happen. 160 00:08:15,053 --> 00:08:18,575 Collection for those tariffs stops on February 24th. 161 00:08:18,725 --> 00:08:24,948 On March 6th, the CBP reports that 53 million import entries were subject 162 00:08:25,098 --> 00:08:30,752 to these tariffs, these duties from more than 330,000 importers. 163 00:08:30,902 --> 00:08:34,825 So on April twentieth, just c a month later after the March date, 164 00:08:34,825 --> 00:08:39,220 it opens the first phase of a refund portal that it calls CAPE. 165 00:08:39,370 --> 00:08:42,412 And CAPE serves importers of record, 166 00:08:42,473 --> 00:08:44,775 those exact same people who are on that list. 167 00:08:44,925 --> 00:08:47,270 There's no box for I bought the head shrimmer then. 168 00:08:47,420 --> 00:08:50,801 No, there's no box for that. It's basically just splitting rent with 169 00:08:50,801 --> 00:08:54,051 a roommate when only the roommate is the one on the lease. 170 00:08:54,201 --> 00:08:57,451 You paid half every month. When you both move out, 171 00:08:57,451 --> 00:09:00,122 the landlord sends the security deposit to the name on the lease. 172 00:09:00,122 --> 00:09:04,207 And whether you see any of it is really up to the quality of your roommate. 173 00:09:04,207 --> 00:09:06,587 If you were my roommate, I know you'd give it back to me. 174 00:09:06,737 --> 00:09:08,728 But in this case, they don't necessarily have to. 175 00:09:08,878 --> 00:09:11,292 Right. And if they just put down a down payment on a boat, 176 00:09:11,292 --> 00:09:13,196 you can probably guess what's gonna happen with the refund. 177 00:09:13,346 --> 00:09:16,561 No nobody would nobody would have a problem with that except the guy who'd 178 00:09:16,561 --> 00:09:20,733 been paying rent. The the roommate is is having a great quarter in this scenario, 179 00:09:20,733 --> 00:09:25,374 right? Because here is what actually happens on the company's ledger sheet, 180 00:09:25,374 --> 00:09:28,525 the actual books. A refund like this comes in as income, 181 00:09:28,675 --> 00:09:30,955 which means that profit actually goes up. 182 00:09:31,105 --> 00:09:34,696 At these companies, bonuses essentially get calculated off of profit. 183 00:09:34,846 --> 00:09:40,478 Securities experts told ProPublica that Stanley Blackendecker's refund looked like 184 00:09:40,478 --> 00:09:42,208 it was lifting its profits, right? 185 00:09:42,208 --> 00:09:45,949 So, and profit is an input to the company's bonus formulas. 186 00:09:46,099 --> 00:09:48,800 The formula has no line for where the money came from, 187 00:09:48,800 --> 00:09:50,630 like a dollar from selling a drill, 188 00:09:50,630 --> 00:09:52,571 or a dollar from the treasury, 189 00:09:52,571 --> 00:09:55,362 or a dollar from an income tax refund. 190 00:09:55,362 --> 00:09:58,773 Basically, it just looks identical to the bean counters. 191 00:09:58,923 --> 00:10:01,414 And here's how TJX booked it. 192 00:10:01,564 --> 00:10:05,267 According to its filings and reportings in WWD, 193 00:10:05,267 --> 00:10:12,223 the retail trade paper, TJX estimates it paid about $490 million in IEPA 194 00:10:12,223 --> 00:10:16,286 tariffs. So far, it's gotten about $331 million of that back. 195 00:10:16,436 --> 00:10:22,291 It accrued $112 million for year-end incentive pay and discretionary bonuses. 196 00:10:22,441 --> 00:10:26,623 Accrude is doing a lot of the work here because it means it recorded the cost 197 00:10:26,623 --> 00:10:29,855 now for money that it intends to pay out later. 198 00:10:30,005 --> 00:10:34,507 The other $219 million went into pre-tax profit for the second quarter 199 00:10:34,727 --> 00:10:36,318 of its fiscal 2027. 200 00:10:36,468 --> 00:10:37,881 And that's discretionary, right? 201 00:10:37,881 --> 00:10:40,517 So anybody or somebody gets to decide what happens to it. 202 00:10:40,667 --> 00:10:41,238 Who gets it? 203 00:10:41,033 --> 00:10:41,643 Exactly. 204 00:10:41,643 --> 00:10:43,804 There's nothing stopping somebody going from saying, 205 00:10:43,804 --> 00:10:45,764 hey, look, this actually didn't come in this way. 206 00:10:45,914 --> 00:10:48,375 Let's actually put it back to our customers and give them to them 207 00:10:48,375 --> 00:10:53,210 as a bonus. But they all have to show year over year uh return on investment 208 00:10:53,210 --> 00:10:57,251 and and year over year profit growth within each company, 209 00:10:57,251 --> 00:11:01,271 and they can also give themselves a piece of that bonus. 210 00:11:01,421 --> 00:11:06,342 American Eagle in September filed what's called an eight K with the SEC. 211 00:11:06,492 --> 00:11:09,403 It's a form that a company files when something happens, 212 00:11:09,843 --> 00:11:13,506 essentially that the investors of that company need to know about right away. 213 00:11:13,506 --> 00:11:15,146 It's like an emergency beacon. 214 00:11:15,296 --> 00:11:18,037 $196 million in tariff refunds, 215 00:11:18,037 --> 00:11:24,581 including interest. So $35 million in extra incentive compensation were tied 216 00:11:24,581 --> 00:11:27,943 to those refunds. Net boost to operating incomes, 217 00:11:27,943 --> 00:11:30,614 about $161 million, and a cushionet, 218 00:11:30,614 --> 00:11:33,116 the tightless people, get $45 million back. 219 00:11:33,116 --> 00:11:33,428 And 220 00:11:33,428 --> 00:11:35,129 12 million set aside for bonuses, 221 00:11:35,129 --> 00:11:38,642 and the company just declined to answer ProPublica's questions. 222 00:11:38,642 --> 00:11:40,043 We didn't, we didn't contact them. 223 00:11:40,304 --> 00:11:42,365 We figured they wouldn't respond to us either. 224 00:11:42,805 --> 00:11:47,127 So who sits on the receiving end of these mathematical formulas? 225 00:11:47,127 --> 00:11:48,959 Well, at Stanley Black and Decker, 226 00:11:49,109 --> 00:11:53,653 Donald Allen Jr. was the CEO when the price hikes actually went through. 227 00:11:53,803 --> 00:11:56,034 He's executive chairman now, right? 228 00:11:56,034 --> 00:12:00,328 So his 2025 base salary was 135 million dollars. 229 00:12:00,478 --> 00:12:05,310 And his target bonus was raised to a hundred and sixty percent of his salary. 230 00:12:05,310 --> 00:12:07,355 I don't even know, these numbers don't even make sense, 231 00:12:07,365 --> 00:12:08,806 as a real human being. I'm like, 232 00:12:08,806 --> 00:12:12,500 can you imagine if your your boss calls you and goes, 233 00:12:12,500 --> 00:12:13,591 Hey, we had a good year this year, 234 00:12:13,591 --> 00:12:16,654 you're gonna get a hundred and sixty percent of your salary back as your annual 235 00:12:16,654 --> 00:12:20,508 bonus. Now these people live in a completely different price range 236 00:12:20,508 --> 00:12:23,180 and you know, salary target from the rest of us will, 237 00:12:23,180 --> 00:12:23,791 wouldn't you say? 238 00:12:23,791 --> 00:12:24,341 I would. 239 00:12:24,341 --> 00:12:29,525 So this target bonus that is what an executive gets if the company hits 240 00:12:29,525 --> 00:12:32,087 its goals, written as a percentage of salary. 241 00:12:32,237 --> 00:12:34,659 The man who took over as CEO on October 1st, 242 00:12:34,659 --> 00:12:39,183 2025, Christopher Nelson, gets a $1.3 million base salary. 243 00:12:39,333 --> 00:12:41,514 So he's making slightly less than the old guy, 244 00:12:41,514 --> 00:12:47,990 this, but gets the same 160% target bonus and a target of 10.345 million in stock 245 00:12:47,990 --> 00:12:50,082 awards for 2026, which means 246 00:12:50,232 --> 00:12:53,934 That his bonus alone comes to $2.08 million. 247 00:12:54,154 --> 00:12:55,855 If the company hits its numbers. 248 00:12:56,005 --> 00:12:58,176 And the refund raises the profit, 249 00:12:58,176 --> 00:12:59,707 those numbers get measured against. 250 00:12:59,857 --> 00:13:02,459 So your your baseline here is rising. 251 00:13:02,609 --> 00:13:04,370 And so do his bonuses. 252 00:13:05,056 --> 00:13:05,869 I think we're so so 253 00:13:05,551 --> 00:13:05,869 Now 254 00:13:05,869 --> 00:13:07,112 far we're up to triple dipping. 255 00:13:07,112 --> 00:13:08,567 I don't know how much further it goes, 256 00:13:08,567 --> 00:13:08,968 but 257 00:13:08,968 --> 00:13:12,121 Right. if all you gotta do is change change C CEOs a couple times and 258 00:13:12,121 --> 00:13:13,782 we get to claw way more of that money back. 259 00:13:13,932 --> 00:13:17,154 Over at TJX, the the CEO is Ernie Herman. 260 00:13:17,304 --> 00:13:20,886 The AFL CIO, which is the Federation of Labor Unions, 261 00:13:20,886 --> 00:13:22,157 we've talked about them before, 262 00:13:22,307 --> 00:13:25,369 tracks executive pay in a database called Paywatch. 263 00:13:25,519 --> 00:13:28,151 it puts Herman's total pay for fiscal 2025 264 00:13:28,151 --> 00:13:34,686 at $23,482,528. 265 00:13:34,957 --> 00:13:41,105 That is one thousand five hundred and sixty-five times what the median TJ Maxx 266 00:13:41,105 --> 00:13:45,923 employee made. Keep that number in your your pocket here because we'll we'll pull 267 00:13:45,923 --> 00:13:47,034 that back a little bit later. 268 00:13:47,184 --> 00:13:50,626 Meanwhile, before anybody knew whether there would be refunds on the tariffs, 269 00:13:50,626 --> 00:13:52,157 the claims already had a price on them. 270 00:13:52,307 --> 00:13:56,589 In July 2025, that's seven months before the Supreme Court ruled on the learning 271 00:13:56,589 --> 00:14:00,672 resources case. Cantor Fitzgerald was reported to be buying the rights to tariff 272 00:14:00,672 --> 00:14:03,043 refunds at twenty to thirty cents on the dollar. 273 00:14:03,193 --> 00:14:06,074 So now there's a derivatives market on tariff refunds. 274 00:14:06,630 --> 00:14:08,484 Yeah, it's it's like pork pig ears. 275 00:14:06,735 --> 00:14:08,035 Cantor's the Wall Street firm. 276 00:14:08,753 --> 00:14:13,116 Yeah, right. Cantor is the Wall Street firm Howard Ludnick ran before he became, 277 00:14:13,196 --> 00:14:13,906 guess what? 278 00:14:13,906 --> 00:14:14,927 Commerce Secretary. 279 00:14:14,521 --> 00:14:15,674 Commerce Secretary. 280 00:14:15,824 --> 00:14:17,625 By then the company was ruled by his, 281 00:14:17,705 --> 00:14:20,248 or sorry, ruled ruled or run, however you want to put it, 282 00:14:20,398 --> 00:14:23,160 by his sons. Brandon Lutnick is the chairman. 283 00:14:23,310 --> 00:14:26,633 Per the Washington Times, Cantor offered importers two million to three million 284 00:14:26,633 --> 00:14:28,975 dollars for every 10 million in duties they paid. 285 00:14:29,125 --> 00:14:32,368 And Cantor says he never executed any any trades with Cantor on that. 286 00:14:32,419 --> 00:14:34,040 All right. So let's let's look at that, 287 00:14:34,040 --> 00:14:35,651 what that looks like on the streets, 288 00:14:35,651 --> 00:14:39,952 right? You are a person who is importing goods from Mexico, 289 00:14:39,952 --> 00:14:42,553 Canada, China, the biggest three there, 290 00:14:42,553 --> 00:14:45,805 right? And you paid $10 million in tariffs. 291 00:14:45,955 --> 00:14:51,057 And a firm run by the sons of a sitting cabinet secretary in the administration 292 00:14:51,057 --> 00:14:57,299 that turned these tariffs on offers you two or three million now for whatever 293 00:14:57,299 --> 00:14:59,560 you'd get back at the tariffs lose in court. 294 00:14:59,710 --> 00:15:02,585 Great deal for the buyer if the buyer thinks the tariffs are going to lose. 295 00:15:02,585 --> 00:15:06,382 But I guess the wor what I wonder is if the Commerce Secretary's kids are offering 296 00:15:06,382 --> 00:15:09,286 you this deal, they must know that the tariffs are going to be paid back. 297 00:15:09,286 --> 00:15:11,471 So that should have been a little bit of a red flag there. 298 00:15:11,621 --> 00:15:13,982 Theoretically, they shouldn't know, 299 00:15:13,982 --> 00:15:16,234 but we 300 00:15:15,794 --> 00:15:16,234 Right. 301 00:15:16,234 --> 00:15:19,976 have a long track record now to to prove that they probably did. 302 00:15:20,126 --> 00:15:24,178 Cantor's position is that no trades actually like happened. 303 00:15:24,178 --> 00:15:27,120 Nothing really occurred, and nothing we found, 304 00:15:27,120 --> 00:15:31,283 you know, through our research and various other means says that there were 305 00:15:31,283 --> 00:15:32,704 any trades that actually went through. 306 00:15:32,854 --> 00:15:35,485 But here's what did happen on paper: 307 00:15:35,485 --> 00:15:37,686 an investor named Thomas. 308 00:15:37,836 --> 00:15:42,266 Brazial at a firm called 117 Partners or 117 Partners, 309 00:15:42,266 --> 00:15:47,919 I'm not sure, bought $925,000 in refund claims with its own money, 310 00:15:48,069 --> 00:15:50,229 betting that the tariffs would get struck down. 311 00:15:50,379 --> 00:15:55,100 So American Eagles' own SEC filing says it sold some of its refund claims 312 00:15:55,250 --> 00:16:00,062 in the prior fiscal year to a buyer that it will not name and doesn't really have 313 00:16:00,062 --> 00:16:00,412 to. 314 00:16:00,412 --> 00:16:04,103 And recorded $45 million in expenses on that deal. 315 00:16:04,253 --> 00:16:09,616 Which and law firms are also filing refund claims for importers on contingency. 316 00:16:09,766 --> 00:16:11,866 One of those is McCune Law Group. 317 00:16:11,986 --> 00:16:14,787 They have a 20% fee as an example. 318 00:16:14,937 --> 00:16:19,909 So by the time that Customs and Border Protection opened that online portal, 319 00:16:20,059 --> 00:16:22,100 there was an actual whole market. 320 00:16:22,100 --> 00:16:25,120 This is like couchy for tariffs at this point, 321 00:16:25,103 --> 00:16:25,428 Mm-hmm. 322 00:16:25,120 --> 00:16:25,610 right? 323 00:16:25,610 --> 00:16:26,950 With investor money. 324 00:16:27,196 --> 00:16:30,256 Which is Wall Street money, lawyers working for a cut. 325 00:16:30,406 --> 00:16:33,507 Every single one of them had a route to the refund. 326 00:16:33,767 --> 00:16:36,608 Or Rothschild, the guy we talked about earlier. 327 00:16:36,758 --> 00:16:39,319 Also with a name like Or, and it's just O R, 328 00:16:39,379 --> 00:16:40,819 not even O R E, not 329 00:16:40,306 --> 00:16:40,819 Right. 330 00:16:40,819 --> 00:16:45,231 O A R, just Or Rothschild. He he should be the perfect attorney, 331 00:16:45,231 --> 00:16:49,152 because then he could just add on to anybody else's attorney firm and then just 332 00:16:49,152 --> 00:16:52,742 be or Rothschild, who basically bought the hedge trimmer. 333 00:16:52,892 --> 00:16:53,392 Has 334 00:16:53,392 --> 00:16:55,507 A lawsuit currently in Connecticut. 335 00:16:55,878 --> 00:16:59,074 Okay, let's talk about the company side because some of it's real and we should 336 00:16:59,074 --> 00:17:00,768 give it credit where credit is due. 337 00:17:00,918 --> 00:17:05,991 Okay, fine, if I have to. So I guess the strongest piece of this it's legal, 338 00:17:06,141 --> 00:17:09,953 all of it. Like CVP doesn't actually put restrictions on how importers 339 00:17:09,953 --> 00:17:12,814 use the refunds. If the company paid the duty, 340 00:17:12,964 --> 00:17:15,726 and then the duty was later found to be illegal, 341 00:17:15,876 --> 00:17:18,457 and the government sends the duty back to whoever paid it, 342 00:17:18,457 --> 00:17:21,578 also the middle schooler and me keeps saying duty. 343 00:17:21,578 --> 00:17:23,269 Um I I 344 00:17:22,298 --> 00:17:23,367 I gonna say there's a lot of dirty 345 00:17:23,367 --> 00:17:24,203 going on around here. 346 00:17:24,058 --> 00:17:24,238 it's 347 00:17:24,238 --> 00:17:27,344 a lot of duty. I am gonna go with tariff, 348 00:17:27,344 --> 00:17:30,080 I think. just to avoid so much duty. 349 00:17:30,230 --> 00:17:31,230 I don't want to step into anything. 350 00:17:31,325 --> 00:17:35,259 Anyway, if they send it who it back to whoever actually paid it, 351 00:17:35,259 --> 00:17:38,972 right? So N Nick Guest, who is an accounting professor at Cornell, 352 00:17:39,122 --> 00:17:41,654 told the same people from PoPublica, 353 00:17:41,654 --> 00:17:44,957 which is where we source the majority of the research from, 354 00:17:45,107 --> 00:17:49,843 uh, the argument for refund-based bonuses could basically go both ways. 355 00:17:49,993 --> 00:17:54,286 And legal analysts quoted in the Hartford Business Journal and CT Mirror. 356 00:17:54,436 --> 00:17:58,331 doubt the consumer lawsuits are actually going to to actually succeed, 357 00:17:58,992 --> 00:18:02,577 but nothing in the in the record says any of these companies broke a law. 358 00:18:02,638 --> 00:18:05,531 I mean, there's just no law here that was broken. 359 00:18:05,681 --> 00:18:08,381 Right, which is the absence of the law may be the problem. 360 00:18:08,531 --> 00:18:12,862 Yes. And a as is a lot of a lot of what we're dealing with nowadays. 361 00:18:12,862 --> 00:18:17,803 And this administration seems to be really good at finding those gigantic loopholes 362 00:18:17,803 --> 00:18:21,665 and then exploiting them to the end of their abilities without ever closing them. 363 00:18:21,815 --> 00:18:22,236 So we'll 364 00:18:21,828 --> 00:18:22,236 Right. 365 00:18:22,236 --> 00:18:23,907 get there. the the second part of this, 366 00:18:23,907 --> 00:18:28,829 I guess, is the the one that has actual economic background behind it. 367 00:18:28,979 --> 00:18:33,521 The estimates of how much of that tariff costs ends up on 368 00:18:33,671 --> 00:18:37,023 consumers, right? And they're all over the United States. 369 00:18:37,173 --> 00:18:40,494 The the New York Fed, the which is the regional branch of the Federal Reserve, 370 00:18:40,644 --> 00:18:44,645 estimated consumers had about 26% of those costs. 371 00:18:44,645 --> 00:18:48,638 So researchers at Harvard Business School put it around 43%. 372 00:18:48,788 --> 00:18:50,849 And then Senator Elizabeth Warren, 373 00:18:50,999 --> 00:18:52,850 one of our favorites here on the show, 374 00:18:53,000 --> 00:18:55,091 has cited n ninety-five percent. 375 00:18:55,091 --> 00:18:56,944 So I you know, it's it's kind of all over the 376 00:18:56,488 --> 00:18:57,401 Sounds accurate. 377 00:18:57,401 --> 00:19:02,003 Yeah, it's it's all over the map and on exactly how much was actually paid 378 00:19:02,003 --> 00:19:07,156 by consumers. But whatever consumers didn't pay essentially got eaten 379 00:19:07,156 --> 00:19:09,147 up somewhere along the supply chain. 380 00:19:09,297 --> 00:19:11,648 And a lot of it by the companies themselves. 381 00:19:11,648 --> 00:19:15,269 So the company's case basically is this we absorbed most of this, 382 00:19:15,419 --> 00:19:20,501 whether it be fuel costs or extra pay for overtime work or whatever. 383 00:19:20,641 --> 00:19:22,552 Basically, they say it came out of our margins. 384 00:19:22,702 --> 00:19:26,598 And this refund essentially replaces money that we lost and otherwise would have 385 00:19:26,598 --> 00:19:27,670 had had the tariffs not 386 00:19:27,820 --> 00:19:29,890 But it came out of the margins for the company. 387 00:19:29,890 --> 00:19:31,622 It didn't come out of the CEO's pocket. 388 00:19:31,772 --> 00:19:34,654 It's not that I'm aware. but I'll I'll give them that to some extent. 389 00:19:34,804 --> 00:19:37,385 Let's you if T J Max eight three quarters of the tariff, 390 00:19:37,385 --> 00:19:39,286 then the refund on that part I guess is theirs, 391 00:19:39,386 --> 00:19:41,377 right? Just refilling that coffer. 392 00:19:41,527 --> 00:19:46,688 I guess a little bit. if you run TJX's number through the lowest estimate, 393 00:19:46,838 --> 00:19:50,800 TJ X said it paid about four hundred and ninety million dollars in these tariffs. 394 00:19:51,981 --> 00:19:57,671 so say T J Max Shoppers paid the same share that the New York Fed estimated 395 00:19:57,671 --> 00:20:00,062 across the whole economy, which is twenty six percent. 396 00:20:00,212 --> 00:20:01,263 That's an assumption and 397 00:20:01,413 --> 00:20:04,374 Like I said earlier, TJ Maxx hasn't actually published its own figure. 398 00:20:04,374 --> 00:20:07,955 26% of $490 million is about $127 million. 399 00:20:08,175 --> 00:20:12,396 The bonus pool alone is $112 million. 400 00:20:12,546 --> 00:20:16,507 So on the friendliest estimate that we have available to us, 401 00:20:16,657 --> 00:20:21,818 the people who actually bought the products share is bigger than the bonus 402 00:20:21,818 --> 00:20:22,208 pool. 403 00:20:22,208 --> 00:20:24,647 And what if we run it at Harvard's forty three percent number? 404 00:20:24,797 --> 00:20:31,742 It's about 211 million, which is within a few million of the 219 million that TJMX 405 00:20:31,742 --> 00:20:34,701 added to its profits. So then there's Stanley, 406 00:20:34,701 --> 00:20:39,556 Black, and Decker, and the whole we aid it defense runs straight into its own mail. 407 00:20:39,706 --> 00:20:43,818 In November 2024, it told customers that tariffs would require price increases. 408 00:20:43,818 --> 00:20:45,870 And in April, it raised prices, 409 00:20:46,150 --> 00:20:48,972 high single digits, and planned more for the fourth quarter. 410 00:20:49,144 --> 00:20:52,928 Company that sent customers a notice saying they'd be paying for the tariff 411 00:20:53,078 --> 00:20:56,722 has a tough time claiming afterwards that it paid the tariff by itself. 412 00:20:56,797 --> 00:20:58,589 at least on the surface, wouldn't you agree? 413 00:20:58,739 --> 00:21:01,251 I would. it's kinda weird to send a letter to your clients. 414 00:21:01,251 --> 00:21:03,485 It's like a a cease and desist or an empty threat letter. 415 00:21:03,485 --> 00:21:05,809 hey, we're gonna we're gonna pay make you pay for these tariffs. 416 00:21:05,959 --> 00:21:08,186 I don't know what that was supposed to make sales, 417 00:21:08,186 --> 00:21:10,620 make people buy things before the tariffs went into effect or something. 418 00:21:10,620 --> 00:21:11,651 Maybe it was like a genius 419 00:21:11,258 --> 00:21:11,651 I 420 00:21:11,651 --> 00:21:12,651 marketing campaign. 421 00:21:12,693 --> 00:21:13,924 I thought I saw a lot of that. 422 00:21:13,934 --> 00:21:15,536 to be fair, I I saw a lot of that. 423 00:21:15,536 --> 00:21:18,098 get it before the tariffs increase the price on it. 424 00:21:18,248 --> 00:21:20,219 Yeah. So maybe that's what this all is. 425 00:21:21,049 --> 00:21:25,220 anyway, the third piece of our our company side of things is TJ Maxx's. 426 00:21:25,370 --> 00:21:28,501 And I'll take their side on this for the sake of discussion. 427 00:21:28,586 --> 00:21:32,727 this quote, eligible associates globally could mean store workers. 428 00:21:32,877 --> 00:21:35,417 If an assistant manager at Marshalls gets a bonus out of this, 429 00:21:35,618 --> 00:21:38,004 I'm not mad at the assistant manager for getting something. 430 00:21:38,004 --> 00:21:39,859 I mean, they probably don't make a living wage as it is, 431 00:21:39,859 --> 00:21:40,299 so 432 00:21:40,299 --> 00:21:43,001 Yeah, and the the the person that's working in the cash register, 433 00:21:43,001 --> 00:21:45,093 it's not their fault. if they get a bonus, 434 00:21:45,233 --> 00:21:48,015 that actually might be a reasonable use case for the bonuses. 435 00:21:48,165 --> 00:21:53,029 But look at what that that whole like that whole ilk kind of covers, 436 00:21:53,029 --> 00:21:58,313 right? It runs from the CEO to the person stocking throw pillows at at home goods, 437 00:21:58,313 --> 00:22:03,367 and a company that pays its CEO one thousand five hundred and sixty-five times 438 00:22:03,367 --> 00:22:04,878 what its median worker makes. 439 00:22:05,028 --> 00:22:06,654 That split could be, it could be anything, 440 00:22:06,654 --> 00:22:11,660 could be 99.1. TJ Maxx hasn't really said where in that range the money goes. 441 00:22:11,660 --> 00:22:16,364 And until it actually does, the title of this episode technically overstates what 442 00:22:16,364 --> 00:22:18,026 we can really prove about TJ Maxx. 443 00:22:18,176 --> 00:22:22,317 The fourth piece of that is that TJ Maxx says it's gonna invest the refunds 444 00:22:22,337 --> 00:22:24,233 in sharper value. 445 00:22:24,383 --> 00:22:27,505 Sharper values. That's a corporate term if I've ever heard one. 446 00:22:27,655 --> 00:22:28,997 It's kind of like sharper image. 447 00:22:29,097 --> 00:22:32,420 way too expensive for things that shouldn't cost that much. 448 00:22:32,570 --> 00:22:36,163 But as anybody as far as anybody can can actually tell, 449 00:22:36,313 --> 00:22:41,859 that means that the same jacket or same throw pillow might be a little cheaper 450 00:22:41,859 --> 00:22:45,133 at some point by an amount that we're not gonna disclose. 451 00:22:45,583 --> 00:22:47,832 they're sharpening the knives for their supplier suppliers. 452 00:22:47,832 --> 00:22:49,357 That's what they mean by sharper values. 453 00:22:49,918 --> 00:22:50,518 Possibly. 454 00:22:50,081 --> 00:22:50,668 Got it. 455 00:22:50,668 --> 00:22:54,348 Now, some companies say they're doing the the price thing for real. 456 00:22:54,369 --> 00:23:01,120 according to courts, Walmart got a about two point nine billion dollar buyback 457 00:23:01,270 --> 00:23:05,411 and says that it's it's rolling back prices on eleven thousand items, 458 00:23:05,411 --> 00:23:10,142 which might be some of the the beef rollback on prices that we've seen in them 459 00:23:10,142 --> 00:23:11,742 negotiate with Donald Trump about. 460 00:23:11,892 --> 00:23:14,422 It might be, you know, other things. 461 00:23:14,802 --> 00:23:15,802 Burlington can't 462 00:23:15,912 --> 00:23:18,253 I the got about $55 million, right? 463 00:23:18,253 --> 00:23:19,995 And says none of it's going to bonuses, 464 00:23:19,995 --> 00:23:26,644 zero. Target, Costco, uh, ELF Beauty and Tractor Supply have committed 465 00:23:26,644 --> 00:23:30,347 to lowering prices, right? I I'm I mean, 466 00:23:30,347 --> 00:23:32,678 account me skeptical, but if you measure 467 00:23:32,350 --> 00:23:32,678 Right. 468 00:23:32,678 --> 00:23:35,360 that against at least the nine bonus payers, 469 00:23:35,510 --> 00:23:36,484 it they might 470 00:23:36,120 --> 00:23:36,484 Yeah. 471 00:23:36,484 --> 00:23:39,496 be a minority in the companies actually getting refunds. 472 00:23:39,646 --> 00:23:41,427 Yeah, by contrast they look pretty good. 473 00:23:41,502 --> 00:23:44,324 and Burlington is basically T J Maxx's direct competitor. 474 00:23:44,399 --> 00:23:46,390 same off price clothes and home goods, 475 00:23:46,611 --> 00:23:49,743 same kind of tariffs and it says zero into the bonus pool. 476 00:23:49,743 --> 00:23:51,545 So that's that's kudos to them. 477 00:23:51,695 --> 00:23:56,206 Yeah. And uh, that was a choice that all of those other nine companies could have 478 00:23:56,206 --> 00:23:57,636 made as well, right? I I mean, 479 00:23:57,736 --> 00:24:01,597 the problem with the rest of the list is the word pricing. 480 00:24:01,747 --> 00:24:06,418 Common Dreams reported this week that the companies promising to return refunds 481 00:24:06,418 --> 00:24:11,450 through pricing have been perhaps deliberately vague about I guess what that 482 00:24:11,450 --> 00:24:13,880 means. Walmart's rollbacks, I mean, 483 00:24:13,880 --> 00:24:15,731 some of them are real. Like you you can actually 484 00:24:15,925 --> 00:24:20,436 Go and see the we actually have a a listener of our show who tried creating 485 00:24:20,436 --> 00:24:24,717 a YouTube channel to go between different Walmarts and and constantly compare 486 00:24:24,717 --> 00:24:27,337 prices. And for that he got kicked off of YouTube. 487 00:24:27,487 --> 00:24:28,927 But check for yourself, you know, 488 00:24:28,927 --> 00:24:31,844 you might be able to to to look at the difference in prices. 489 00:24:31,844 --> 00:24:34,485 Supposedly beef is lower, supposedly eggs are lower, 490 00:24:34,485 --> 00:24:36,695 things like that. I mean, when I go to Walmart, 491 00:24:36,995 --> 00:24:38,646 I I have to pay attention to those. 492 00:24:38,646 --> 00:24:40,817 I'm trying to use the great. 493 00:24:40,967 --> 00:24:44,860 uh great value and what's what's their new one that I really like it's something it's 494 00:24:44,890 --> 00:24:45,840 like Good and Gather. 495 00:24:44,944 --> 00:24:45,944 Greater value. 496 00:24:45,990 --> 00:24:48,771 No, I wish that'd be nice. It's gosh, 497 00:24:48,771 --> 00:24:50,102 what is it? It was I don't know. 498 00:24:50,142 --> 00:24:56,606 It's like they're they're supposedly more premium line and they it it's kind of like 499 00:24:56,606 --> 00:24:59,358 Good and Gather. I think it's better and the best or I don't know. 500 00:24:59,398 --> 00:25:03,259 Who cares? Anyway, I I mean the the point I'm trying to make I think is that 501 00:25:03,409 --> 00:25:07,601 Perhaps they are actually cutting the real prices. 502 00:25:07,751 --> 00:25:09,452 And maybe they're gonna pass those down to people. 503 00:25:09,602 --> 00:25:12,975 But after all that, the the part that sticks out to me the most is the fact that 504 00:25:12,975 --> 00:25:15,446 all this is legal, none of this is against the law. 505 00:25:15,531 --> 00:25:17,592 you can you can bill customers whatever you want. 506 00:25:17,592 --> 00:25:21,794 To me, this would be the equivalent of price gouging and then being caught doing 507 00:25:21,794 --> 00:25:25,556 it, and you pay the fine to the government instead of paying back the customers. 508 00:25:25,726 --> 00:25:27,377 wait, that's how that works too. 509 00:25:27,527 --> 00:25:31,874 So, the the part I guess that comes down to it is the consumer share is the part 510 00:25:31,874 --> 00:25:36,165 that they mention in vagities and put them in parentheses and things like that. 511 00:25:36,165 --> 00:25:40,537 But and maybe the the companies did actually absorb some money. 512 00:25:41,478 --> 00:25:47,099 but if any of these companies take this money and use it for bonuses, 513 00:25:47,249 --> 00:25:49,951 I think that that's something that we really need to pay attention to, 514 00:25:49,951 --> 00:25:50,861 right? And and 515 00:25:50,861 --> 00:25:54,523 Even if it's at the the low estimate of what what shoppers actually paid, 516 00:25:54,673 --> 00:25:58,065 if they paid anything like the the average share, 517 00:25:58,065 --> 00:26:00,797 I think that that would probably work out for most people, 518 00:26:00,797 --> 00:26:02,338 but in most cases it doesn't. 519 00:26:02,488 --> 00:26:02,992 True. 520 00:26:02,992 --> 00:26:04,033 All right, let's go back to Mr. 521 00:26:04,033 --> 00:26:08,258 O. R. Rothschild for a minute here because he's about as well set up as a shopper 522 00:26:08,258 --> 00:26:10,961 can be. Uh he has has the job background. 523 00:26:11,111 --> 00:26:14,615 He has the company's own letter saying tariffs would mean higher prices. 524 00:26:14,765 --> 00:26:18,388 He has lawyers. He's one of at least two suits filed against Stanley Black 525 00:26:18,388 --> 00:26:21,542 and Decker in Connecticut, and legal analysts still doubt those suits will 526 00:26:21,542 --> 00:26:22,133 succeed. 527 00:26:22,133 --> 00:26:27,099 Yeah, I think it's because his case is standing in opposition to the the refund 528 00:26:27,099 --> 00:26:31,120 process, right? That says the money belongs to the importer with no conditions 529 00:26:31,120 --> 00:26:33,651 attached. There's not a little asterisk or small print or anything. 530 00:26:33,801 --> 00:26:35,441 Rothschild I mean 531 00:26:35,591 --> 00:26:37,702 doesn't have really a claim on the form. 532 00:26:37,742 --> 00:26:43,755 The the the C V P has a form entry number there and he's a corporate executive 533 00:26:43,895 --> 00:26:45,215 and it really doesn't help him. 534 00:26:45,215 --> 00:26:48,535 So I guess what decides it is whose name is on the customs form. 535 00:26:48,535 --> 00:26:51,005 And put that next to Thomas Brazielle, 536 00:26:51,005 --> 00:26:55,007 right? Who spent nine hundred and twenty five thousand buying up the refund claims 537 00:26:55,007 --> 00:26:57,678 and and he owns a route to the money. 538 00:26:57,678 --> 00:26:58,714 So he might actually get paid. 539 00:26:58,714 --> 00:26:59,204 So 540 00:26:59,204 --> 00:27:04,312 Rothschild who only spent his money on the the snowblower or the wrench or the hedge 541 00:27:04,312 --> 00:27:08,398 trimmer or whatever. All he owns at this point is a lawsuit with a a prayer 542 00:27:08,398 --> 00:27:09,440 at the outcome. 543 00:27:09,590 --> 00:27:11,571 he's the best case scenario for that group. 544 00:27:12,331 --> 00:27:13,692 but I do think it's interesting that, 545 00:27:13,692 --> 00:27:17,583 you know, they can assign the the right the refund rights to someone else, 546 00:27:17,683 --> 00:27:20,714 like who buys it. Basically he went to them and bought their right to claim 547 00:27:20,714 --> 00:27:25,035 the refund. But they can't track what has gone and what's been passed along 548 00:27:25,035 --> 00:27:28,640 to the customer. which is kind of kind of a weird dynamic, 549 00:27:28,640 --> 00:27:30,940 I guess. But anyway, for TJ Maxx shoppers, 550 00:27:30,940 --> 00:27:32,671 there's no lawsuit in anything we found. 551 00:27:32,781 --> 00:27:33,882 they they haven't done anything, 552 00:27:33,882 --> 00:27:37,681 they violated any laws. proof public is reporting and the suits on file 553 00:27:37,681 --> 00:27:39,663 are all about Stanley Black and Decker, 554 00:27:39,813 --> 00:27:43,095 given that they said, what they were doing with the terrorists and then never paid 555 00:27:43,215 --> 00:27:46,078 back. the person who paid it a marshal's register doesn't appear in this story 556 00:27:46,078 --> 00:27:48,910 anywhere except his revenue on TJ Maxx's bottom line. 557 00:27:49,060 --> 00:27:51,223 Yeah, there's there's a bunch of T J Maxxes here. 558 00:27:51,223 --> 00:27:52,280 I've never been in one, have you? 559 00:27:52,430 --> 00:27:55,533 yes, I I unfortunately have. my s my wife 560 00:27:54,755 --> 00:27:55,533 to Burlington. 561 00:27:55,533 --> 00:27:58,454 is a always a fan. but you know, 562 00:27:58,604 --> 00:28:01,645 there's there's some there's a bunch of North Carolina and Texas and everywhere 563 00:28:01,645 --> 00:28:02,596 else it seems like. 564 00:28:02,596 --> 00:28:04,278 All the blue states. Say 565 00:28:03,698 --> 00:28:04,541 Hey, what do you know? 566 00:28:04,541 --> 00:28:06,912 it's yeah, right. I mean, it's the same jacket, 567 00:28:06,912 --> 00:28:09,244 right? It's the same, the same tax, 568 00:28:09,244 --> 00:28:12,876 it's the same price bump on no matter what the product was. 569 00:28:12,876 --> 00:28:15,798 And the and the shopper in the TJ Maxx and in the Marshalls, 570 00:28:15,798 --> 00:28:17,659 they have the same number of ways to get it back, 571 00:28:17,659 --> 00:28:19,150 which right now is currently zero. 572 00:28:19,150 --> 00:28:22,041 It's just a hope and a prayer and that your roommate's not an asshole. 573 00:28:22,191 --> 00:28:24,992 You got Warren and Booker and and Welch, 574 00:28:24,992 --> 00:28:27,874 those the senators up there estimated that these tariffs 575 00:28:28,024 --> 00:28:30,476 cost the average family about $1,700. 576 00:28:30,476 --> 00:28:32,657 Now that's the the estimate, right? 577 00:28:32,657 --> 00:28:37,620 And the the consumer share fight from a a a few minutes ago applies to the same 578 00:28:37,620 --> 00:28:40,862 concept, right? Even if your number is half that and you've only paid, 579 00:28:40,882 --> 00:28:44,225 $14 or what's half of $1,700? $800, 580 00:28:44,285 --> 00:28:47,127 $750, $850. Yeah. I 581 00:28:44,700 --> 00:28:47,054 eight fifty, yeah, I think. Yeah. 582 00:28:47,127 --> 00:28:48,998 knew it was between there. Anyway, 583 00:28:49,081 --> 00:28:50,849 uh, even if your numbers are half that, 584 00:28:50,849 --> 00:28:52,521 right? There's no, there's no like 585 00:28:52,875 --> 00:28:54,749 Claim form. There's no refund. 586 00:28:54,749 --> 00:28:59,800 There's no place you can sell to Cantor for 20 bucks to to see whether 587 00:28:59,800 --> 00:29:02,075 or not you you get your 1700 back, 588 00:29:02,075 --> 00:29:02,456 right? 589 00:29:02,456 --> 00:29:06,427 Right. So let's say you're a listener and you want to do the the obvious move 590 00:29:06,427 --> 00:29:09,738 of figuring out if you got a refund or if the store you shop at got a refund 591 00:29:09,888 --> 00:29:12,469 and how much of it went to the bonuses for their executives. 592 00:29:12,544 --> 00:29:15,645 the people unfortunately who don't have to tell you are the private importers among 593 00:29:15,645 --> 00:29:18,456 those three hundred and thirty thousand who don't file anything in public. 594 00:29:18,696 --> 00:29:21,801 you know, those are those can be lots of different types of parties that that 595 00:29:21,801 --> 00:29:23,612 receive the goods and make the tariff payments. 596 00:29:24,208 --> 00:29:26,061 And a lot of times they're just pass through parties. 597 00:29:24,592 --> 00:29:25,592 the administration. 598 00:29:26,211 --> 00:29:27,211 Yeah, exactly. 599 00:29:27,321 --> 00:29:30,013 the administration turned down ProPublica's record records request 600 00:29:30,013 --> 00:29:36,577 on the refunds. and so then of course TJ Maxx says it can't say how it's $110 601 00:29:36,577 --> 00:29:39,399 million splits until the final fiscal year ends. 602 00:29:39,549 --> 00:29:42,376 So once they get all their their their numbers together at the end of the year, 603 00:29:42,376 --> 00:29:46,337 presumably they'll they'll go back and add it in a footnote to some earlier report. 604 00:29:46,337 --> 00:29:48,779 m But 605 00:29:48,256 --> 00:29:50,556 So really the only you know outlook that 606 00:29:50,556 --> 00:29:54,637 anybody has in this is your your S the SEC filing. 607 00:29:54,637 --> 00:29:57,948 So SEC filings are typically written for investors. 608 00:29:57,948 --> 00:29:59,749 Normally they get leaked, or you know, 609 00:29:59,969 --> 00:30:03,460 institutional investor will have access to those PDFs that they send out. 610 00:30:03,460 --> 00:30:09,762 It it just told investors that TJ Mox Max's profit went up 219 million dollars, 611 00:30:09,762 --> 00:30:11,782 right? And nobody's required to write. 612 00:30:11,932 --> 00:30:13,663 The version for the customer that goes, 613 00:30:13,663 --> 00:30:19,396 hey, just so your your costs and your prices went up by $1,700 this year. 614 00:30:19,636 --> 00:30:23,998 There's a a line in in ProPublica's article and writing about this from 615 00:30:23,998 --> 00:30:28,920 Gregory Germain. He called executive bonuses probably the least just 616 00:30:28,920 --> 00:30:32,532 way to use this money because it was the government mistake. 617 00:30:32,632 --> 00:30:34,813 I mean, it's what it was. It was a mistake. 618 00:30:34,813 --> 00:30:36,264 It illegally used power. 619 00:30:36,414 --> 00:30:38,425 That produced the refund in the first place, 620 00:30:38,425 --> 00:30:41,896 right? And when you walk through what that means, 621 00:30:41,896 --> 00:30:45,748 the government imposed a tax that had no authority to actually put 622 00:30:45,748 --> 00:30:50,652 on to the people. The companies took on the job of tax collector and collected 623 00:30:50,652 --> 00:30:53,313 that tax from you. And some of them told you, 624 00:30:53,313 --> 00:30:54,814 you know, in a letter or an email, 625 00:30:54,814 --> 00:30:58,316 or you might have gotten a uh postcard in your post office box. 626 00:30:58,316 --> 00:31:00,757 But the government admits that the mistake, 627 00:31:00,757 --> 00:31:02,528 right? Sends the money back to the companies. 628 00:31:02,678 --> 00:31:04,952 And the nine of that that we know at least, 629 00:31:04,973 --> 00:31:06,796 part of it came in bonus pay. 630 00:31:06,946 --> 00:31:11,742 And the refunds already out the door are past the one hundred billion dollar mark. 631 00:31:11,742 --> 00:31:14,296 So whatever happens with the FTC or the lawsuits, 632 00:31:14,296 --> 00:31:16,118 that money's been paid to the names in the form. 633 00:31:16,268 --> 00:31:21,952 Yeah. So if you go back to the November twenty twenty four letter from Stanley 634 00:31:21,952 --> 00:31:23,789 Blackendecker telling customers that, 635 00:31:23,789 --> 00:31:25,574 you know, tariffs would increase the prices. 636 00:31:25,574 --> 00:31:28,976 For pricing, the company treated you as a person paying the tariff. 637 00:31:29,126 --> 00:31:32,989 Now for the refund, customs law treats the company as the one who paid. 638 00:31:33,139 --> 00:31:36,261 And both are true right now at the same time, 639 00:31:36,261 --> 00:31:38,272 right? And the company just collects under both. 640 00:31:38,422 --> 00:31:41,906 So the reason who gets the refund is the hard question at all is because 641 00:31:41,906 --> 00:31:45,779 the law decides who paid a tax and whose name is on the entry form. 642 00:31:45,929 --> 00:31:49,994 And then lets the same party build the tax into every price it charges. 643 00:31:50,144 --> 00:31:51,876 Somebody wrote that rule somewhere, 644 00:31:51,876 --> 00:31:56,951 right? CBP built its refund portal around the rule that exists. 645 00:31:57,101 --> 00:32:00,425 When you know, this these are the opportunities I feel like where they say, 646 00:32:00,425 --> 00:32:00,865 well, 647 00:32:00,865 --> 00:32:04,369 I believe in the letter of the law or I believe in the rule of law and there 648 00:32:04,369 --> 00:32:06,531 was no rule around this, so there is no law. 649 00:32:07,051 --> 00:32:10,595 but it's been it's been the rule under under presidents of of both parties 650 00:32:10,595 --> 00:32:14,509 at this point, with Trump one and Biden and Trump two now. 651 00:32:15,260 --> 00:32:18,454 So that was a choice somebody made and the bonus formulas are the same kind 652 00:32:18,454 --> 00:32:22,489 of choice. I mean you have a compensation committee on the co on a typical company's 653 00:32:22,489 --> 00:32:26,713 board writes those formulas and decides what counts as profit for bonus purposes. 654 00:32:26,863 --> 00:32:30,346 And at these particular companies we've identified the refunds apparently counted. 655 00:32:30,527 --> 00:32:30,957 So 656 00:32:30,957 --> 00:32:35,400 Yeah. the fixes people are actually talking about and you know, 657 00:32:35,400 --> 00:32:40,293 who who each each formula ends up costing a different person a different thing. 658 00:32:40,443 --> 00:32:44,645 You have seven Senate Democrats that want the FC FTC to investigate under 659 00:32:44,645 --> 00:32:48,406 the FTC Act, which bans deceptive or unfair practices. 660 00:32:48,556 --> 00:32:52,798 So if the FTC decided that raising prices over tariffs and then keeping the refunds 661 00:32:52,798 --> 00:32:54,518 was deceptive, that would 662 00:32:54,660 --> 00:32:56,281 cost the company's actual money. 663 00:32:56,402 --> 00:33:00,051 The person who'd have to act on it though is Andrew Ferguson, 664 00:33:00,051 --> 00:33:02,742 the FTC chairman in this current administration. 665 00:33:02,892 --> 00:33:06,675 So the same administration that actually imposed the tariffs and denied 666 00:33:06,675 --> 00:33:08,516 ProPublica's records requests. 667 00:33:08,666 --> 00:33:12,568 Then there's Warren and Booker and and Welch who actually called this for what 668 00:33:12,568 --> 00:33:15,180 it actually is, which is a theft on the middle class. 669 00:33:15,330 --> 00:33:19,553 And they demanded a plan to refund consumers and small businesses directly. 670 00:33:19,703 --> 00:33:20,784 I mean that that's 671 00:33:20,934 --> 00:33:23,776 To me, what also sounds like the obvious fix, 672 00:33:23,776 --> 00:33:25,737 right? If you run it through the test, 673 00:33:25,887 --> 00:33:27,087 where does the money come from? 674 00:33:27,237 --> 00:33:31,599 If the Treasury cuts checks to families while TJ Maxx and Stanley Black and Deck 675 00:33:31,599 --> 00:33:33,120 and Decker keep their refunds, 676 00:33:33,270 --> 00:33:36,502 the public pays for this illegal tariff twice. 677 00:33:36,652 --> 00:33:39,124 Once at the register and then once out of the federal budget, 678 00:33:39,124 --> 00:33:41,795 which still comes out of our pocket one way or another another, 679 00:33:41,795 --> 00:33:43,915 right? And the companies come out fine. 680 00:33:43,915 --> 00:33:45,426 They they come out smelling like a rose, 681 00:33:45,426 --> 00:33:48,117 honestly. Nothing in in any of this really 682 00:33:48,448 --> 00:33:52,870 has a say in or even the senators would say who who would actually pay for it. 683 00:33:53,020 --> 00:33:57,924 And I think a lot of times the the through pricing promises cost the companies 684 00:33:57,924 --> 00:33:59,555 whatever the companies decide. 685 00:33:59,756 --> 00:34:01,296 And you can't really check them on it. 686 00:34:01,446 --> 00:34:04,338 Two things in this record though that would actually cost somebody at 687 00:34:04,338 --> 00:34:08,442 the top is is refunds that come with a condition attached like passing them 688 00:34:08,442 --> 00:34:12,564 through to customers before the money counts as profit or clawing back bonuses. 689 00:34:12,714 --> 00:34:14,335 that were paid out of refund money, 690 00:34:14,435 --> 00:34:17,257 either one would actually need somebody to write it. 691 00:34:17,257 --> 00:34:22,380 Congress or the an administration willing to at least try it with C V P and and with 692 00:34:22,380 --> 00:34:25,082 more than a hundred billion dollars of this already paid out, 693 00:34:25,082 --> 00:34:29,345 a lot of that money has left the building before anybody in Washington has written 694 00:34:29,345 --> 00:34:29,945 either one. 695 00:34:29,945 --> 00:34:33,867 And regarding the parties, I mean the record is pretty lopsided here. 696 00:34:33,905 --> 00:34:36,178 The tariffs were Trump's. We know that, 697 00:34:36,178 --> 00:34:40,481 that's clear. The record's denial was his administration's the CBP. 698 00:34:40,921 --> 00:34:45,083 The firm reportedly pricing refund claims was run by his Commerce Secretary Sons, 699 00:34:45,233 --> 00:34:47,344 though Cantor denies that any trades took place. 700 00:34:47,494 --> 00:34:51,888 Yeah, the the D Democrats' response so far is strongly written letters, 701 00:34:51,888 --> 00:34:55,290 which is, you know, kind of kind of what got us here in the first place. 702 00:34:55,320 --> 00:34:59,884 you know, a a letter to the F FTC really costs the CEO nothing. 703 00:34:59,944 --> 00:35:04,237 I mean, the importer of record rule that sends the check to the company survived 704 00:35:04,238 --> 00:35:06,219 every single administration before this one, 705 00:35:06,219 --> 00:35:09,402 and nobody in this fight's really introduced any sort of legislation that 706 00:35:09,402 --> 00:35:12,610 changes it. so the question is pretty specific, 707 00:35:12,610 --> 00:35:13,230 and I think. 708 00:35:13,230 --> 00:35:16,207 It really comes into the incoming Congress, 709 00:35:16,357 --> 00:35:20,696 right? Who writes these conditions and can it pass before the next round of money 710 00:35:20,696 --> 00:35:22,360 goes out? Will it get vetoed? Who knows? 711 00:35:22,510 --> 00:35:26,172 Who knows? So if somebody worked brings up tariffs this week or if they read 712 00:35:26,172 --> 00:35:28,680 the Pro Public article, what's the two sentence version? 713 00:35:28,830 --> 00:35:30,271 I don't know, point at the podcast. 714 00:35:30,421 --> 00:35:32,122 You you paid the tariffs, right? 715 00:35:32,122 --> 00:35:36,444 At the register. the Stanley Black and Decker literally mailed a peop people 716 00:35:36,444 --> 00:35:38,915 a letter saying that you were gonna pay these tariffs. 717 00:35:39,065 --> 00:35:42,026 And then when the Supreme Court said the tariffs were illegal, 718 00:35:42,026 --> 00:35:45,088 the refund went to whose ever name was on the customs form. 719 00:35:45,238 --> 00:35:48,109 And TJ Maxx was a about a third of it. 720 00:35:48,259 --> 00:35:51,750 Hundred and twelve million out of three hundred and thirty one million gets 721 00:35:51,750 --> 00:35:53,651 set aside for bonuses. You're welcome. 722 00:35:53,801 --> 00:35:56,305 After being added to profit, which is sick. 723 00:35:55,783 --> 00:35:56,455 Mm-hmm. 724 00:35:56,455 --> 00:35:57,939 And if somebody wants a third sentence, 725 00:35:58,000 --> 00:36:00,879 Burlington got a refund too and says none of it went to bonuses. 726 00:36:00,879 --> 00:36:02,684 So there's a choice that was made here. 727 00:36:02,834 --> 00:36:05,214 Yeah. The thing we're really watching now is the split. 728 00:36:05,364 --> 00:36:08,806 TJ Maxx says it can't break out who gets the hundred and twelve million until 729 00:36:08,806 --> 00:36:11,317 its fiscal year is over. And when that number shows up, 730 00:36:11,317 --> 00:36:15,600 we'll know whether eligible associates globally means the people like folding 731 00:36:15,600 --> 00:36:19,951 sweaters and doing the work or just the people at the top with a fifteen 732 00:36:19,951 --> 00:36:22,122 sixty-five to one pay ratio. 733 00:36:22,272 --> 00:36:24,574 And whether the FTC does anything with those letters. 734 00:36:24,754 --> 00:36:26,012 But I think if they had asked me, 735 00:36:26,012 --> 00:36:30,668 I would have told them to include a rebate form on all their their receipts for items 736 00:36:30,668 --> 00:36:31,859 that had tariffs attached to them. 737 00:36:31,859 --> 00:36:33,750 'Cause those rebates never get paid back, 738 00:36:33,750 --> 00:36:36,492 right? So they could then just use the money to to pay the executives. 739 00:36:36,642 --> 00:36:38,686 I've never had one of those re rebates ever 740 00:36:37,039 --> 00:36:38,574 Even better, it comes as a gift card. 741 00:36:38,686 --> 00:36:40,264 actually produce anything. So yeah. 742 00:36:40,414 --> 00:36:42,345 Or gift card to a non existent company. 743 00:36:42,831 --> 00:36:45,381 Exactly. And then then, you know, 744 00:36:45,391 --> 00:36:47,512 a monthly maintenance fee on the gift card balance. 745 00:36:47,512 --> 00:36:52,611 And anyway, i everything in this episode thirteen CDs for a penny. 746 00:36:47,873 --> 00:36:50,240 Right. And then you s they sign you up for Columbia House, 747 00:36:50,390 --> 00:36:53,279 start getting uh tapes, audio cassettes, 748 00:36:53,279 --> 00:36:53,711 yeah. 749 00:36:53,711 --> 00:36:56,712 Everybody in this everything in this episode came from public reporting 750 00:36:56,712 --> 00:36:58,292 and public filings, pro publica, 751 00:36:58,442 --> 00:37:00,743 the SEC filings, the Hartford Business Journal, 752 00:37:00,743 --> 00:37:03,573 CT Mirror Courts, the Senators own letters, 753 00:37:03,673 --> 00:37:05,794 as well as the Library of Congress that records those. 754 00:37:05,794 --> 00:37:07,334 So you can read every bit of this for yourself. 755 00:37:07,484 --> 00:37:11,108 Remember to do your duty. And if you if you have duty done to you, 756 00:37:11,108 --> 00:37:12,632 then I don't know where that's going. 757 00:37:12,632 --> 00:37:15,216 Okay. You can find us at FOF.foundation 758 00:37:13,216 --> 00:37:14,216 Don't duty there, booty. 759 00:37:15,216 --> 00:37:18,029 and on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. 760 00:37:18,179 --> 00:37:19,701 If you get a story or a correction, 761 00:37:19,901 --> 00:37:23,656 we'd love to hear from you. Email us at the overlap at FOF.foundation. 762 00:37:23,806 --> 00:37:25,078 And if you got something out of this, 763 00:37:25,228 --> 00:37:27,872 give us a five star rating. It helps people find the show. 764 00:37:28,013 --> 00:37:30,807 Share it far and wide. If you see us somewhere on social media, 765 00:37:30,807 --> 00:37:33,510 especially Blue Sky or Mastodon, 766 00:37:33,660 --> 00:37:35,803 give us a follow and and share us there. 767 00:37:35,953 --> 00:37:37,880 And all those things would be kind things to do. 768 00:37:38,101 --> 00:37:39,828 And we always say, be kind to each other. 769 00:37:39,978 --> 00:37:40,978 Help out where you can. 770 00:37:41,021 --> 00:37:43,204 And we always say at the end, bye. 771 00:37:42,935 --> 00:37:43,935 Bye.