Refund Policy: CEOnly
Ep. 88

Refund Policy: CEOnly

•

Episode description

You paid the tariffs at the register. The Supreme Court ruled them illegal. So why is the refund check going to someone else?

Joshua and Will follow the money back out the door: a power tool company that warned you in writing you’d be paying, a refund portal with no box for shoppers, a Wall Street firm tied to a cabinet secretary pricing the claims before the ruling, and bonus formulas that can’t tell a drill sale from a Treasury check. Plus the company side, which holds up better than you’d expect in a couple of spots.

Download transcript (.srt)
0:00

In October 2024, the month before the election,

0:03

the CEO of Stanley Black Decker,

0:06

Donald Allen Jr., told shareholders the company was getting ready for possible

0:11

Trump tariffs. Stanley Black Decker is the Connecticut company behind DeWalt,

0:15

the Yellow Power Tools. A month later,

0:17

in November 2024, the company sent consumers a letter.

0:22

It said tariff actions expected from the incoming administration would require

0:26

price increases.

0:27

Expected. Trump hadn't been sworn in yet.

0:30

The price increases were already in the mail.

0:32

Then the tariff showed up for real.

0:34

In April 2025, Stanley Black and Decker raised prices by what it called a high

0:39

single digit, planned another increase for the fourth quarter,

0:43

and put its tariffs hit at $800 million.

0:47

If you bought a DeWalt Impact Wrench that year,

0:49

the company had already told you in writing who was paying the tariff.

0:53

You were.

0:54

On February 20th, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the emergency law Trump

1:00

used for his tariffs on Canada,

1:01

Mexico, and China, and for the ones he rolled out on what he called Liberation

1:06

Day, never gave him the power to impose tariffs at all.

1:10

The government had collected somewhere between 166 billion and 175 billion

1:15

it had no authority to collect.

1:17

So it has to pay it back.

1:19

Stanley Black and Decker is getting at least $298 million of your money.

1:25

And when the company reported that money,

1:27

it said it was offset by variable incentive compensation.

1:31

Bonuses.

1:32

It's got company, TJX, which owns TJ Maxx,

1:35

Marshalls, and HomeGoods, they got $331 million back and set aside $112 million

1:41

of it for bonuses. American Eagle got $196 million and booked $35 million in extra

1:47

incentive pay. Akushnet, the company that makes tight list golf balls and foot joy,

1:53

got $45 million and put $12 million toward bonuses.

1:57

All of that comes from ProPublica.

1:59

Two of the reporters, Robert,

2:00

Fattorecci and Nick McMillan went through thousands of securities filings

2:05

and earnings calls and found that at least nine publicly traded companies disclosed

2:10

doing this. Their story ran yesterday.

2:12

You paid that tariff at the register at a Marshall's in a red county or a blue

2:17

county, and the register didn't really ask you which.

2:19

When the money came back, it went to whoever's name was on the customs

2:23

paperwork. At TJ Maxx, about a third of it went into the bonus pool.

2:42

This is the Overlap. I'm Will.

2:44

And I am Joshua and I am mad at a power tool company.

2:47

First time for everything.

2:48

You're gonna have to tell me what to cross off your Christmas list.

2:50

Right. So here's the kind of the story in one sentence here,

2:53

right? You paid the tariffs in higher prices.

2:56

The Supreme Court said the tariffs were illegal.

2:59

The government is paying the money back to the companies that imported those goods.

3:03

And some of those companies are paying it out as bonuses.

3:06

Feels like 2008 all over again.

3:08

Um

3:08

Yeah.

3:09

but it all came together in the same week.

3:11

ProPublica's story ran for November on November 16th.

3:15

Five days before that, on November 11th,

3:17

Senate Democrats wrote to Andrew Ferguson,

3:19

the chairman of the Federal Trade Commission,

3:21

which is the agency that polices unfair and deceptive trade business practices,

3:25

and asked him to investigate companies that raised prices over tariffs and kept

3:29

then kept the refunds.

3:30

Th and this week the total paid out in refunds passed a hundred billion dollars.

3:34

The money's already gone out the door.

3:35

So by the end of this, you'll be able to explain to somebody why the check goes

3:39

to the company when the company told you in a letter that you'd be the one paying.

3:44

Y'all know why a bonus formula can't tell the difference between money a company

3:49

made selling drills and money the government sent back.

3:52

And you'll know who was offering to buy up refund claims at a discount before

3:57

the Supreme Court ever made their ruling,

3:59

including a firm run by the Commerce Secretary's son.

4:02

And you'll get the company side,

4:04

which is better than you'd expect in a couple of places.

4:06

Uh starting with the title of this episode,

4:08

which is a little unfair to TJ Maxx.

4:09

A little bit. TJX says the $112 million covers,

4:14

quote, eligible associates globally.

4:17

So some of it, honestly, could go to people working the registers,

4:21

but how much? TJX says it can't break that out until its fiscal year is actually

4:27

over.

4:27

And hopefully we've forgotten this whole thing ever happened.

4:30

Hopefully.

4:31

but

4:31

it's the same, it's the same as Stanley,

4:32

Black, and Decker. Uh the company hasn't disclosed how much of its refund went

4:36

to bonuses or how far down the ranks those bonuses go.

4:39

That split is the piece that hasn't been reported anywhere because the companies

4:43

haven't put it on paper.

4:44

And let's be honest, they probably won't,

4:46

because the government is not filling the gap either.

4:48

ProPublica asked for records on the refunds,

4:51

and the Trump administration denied the request.

4:53

So the only reason we know about these nine companies is that they're publicly

4:59

owned companies. And with publicly owned companies,

5:01

they have to file their finances with the SEC,

5:03

the Securities and Exchange Commission,

5:05

for those of you who don't have a 401.

5:07

Customs and Border Protection,

5:08

the agency that collects the tariffs at the border,

5:11

Counted more than 330 million importers who paid these duties.

5:15

ProPublica could only look at the public ones.

5:17

So three hundred and thirty million or three hundred and thirty thousand?

5:20

Three hundred and thirty thousand importers.

5:22

Okay, got it. but we know that the minimum number of companies we're dealing with

5:26

now are nine companies. And it's what you can count from the one slice of companies

5:30

that have to show their books.

5:31

So the story starts with a form at the border.

5:33

Now, obviously, it doesn't really start at the border.

5:36

These are coming in on chips, and it's all really just a big paperwork trail.

5:39

But the Trump law that he used specifically was called the IEEEPA

5:45

or the International Emergency Economic Powers Act.

5:48

That lets a president take economic actions after declaring a national

5:52

emergency, which on February 2nd,

5:55

2025, he signed three executive orders,

5:58

numbers 14193.

6:00

Through 14195, using the AIPA to put tariffs on goods from Canada,

6:07

Mexico, and China. On April 2nd,

6:09

he announced the Liberation Day tariffs under Executive Order 14257.

6:14

Those are the tariffs the Supreme Court actually threw out.

6:17

A tariff is a tax on imported goods,

6:20

very simply, and somebody has to physically write the check for those

6:23

goods. Maybe not physically, maybe they just.

6:26

Put it in a printer. But that's the importer of record.

6:30

It's essentially the company whose name is actually put on that customs form that

6:34

has to be filled out, which is the paperwork filed when a shipping company

6:38

or a shipment of goods comes into the country.

6:41

So the importer pays customs and border protection.

6:44

After that, the importer decides what to do with the cost.

6:47

It can eat that cost, it can, squeeze some of its suppliers for a lower goods price,

6:53

or

6:53

It can actually put it in the price that it uses to or that it gives to sell those

6:57

goods to somebody else.

6:59

And our good friends as Stanley Black and Decker picked door number three.

7:02

And they announced it before the tariffs even existed,

7:04

which is, nice heads up, at least.

7:06

but that's where Orr Rothschild comes in.

7:08

Uh he's in Wisconsin and he's a finance and strategy executive.

7:12

He bought a bunch of DeWalt tools,

7:14

a handheld blower, an impact wrench,

7:16

a hedge trimmer, and some others.

7:18

Got some serious work done last year.

7:20

according to the Hartford Business Journal,

7:21

he's now using state or sorry.

7:23

Now suing Stanley Blackendecker in Connecticut on behalf of uh all of their

7:27

customers. He's trying to start a putative class action.

7:29

his argument is that the company raised prices because of tariffs.

7:32

And so in that said so in that November 2024 letter.

7:35

And now, in the words of his lawsuit,

7:37

quote, stands to recover the same tariff payments twice.

7:41

So once from him at the checkout,

7:44

right? Like from his wallet, and then once from the government.

7:47

And here's kind of how the second one works.

7:51

February 20th, 2026, the Supreme Court basically decides learning resources

7:56

versus Trump six to three. IEPA doesn't actually authorize the president to impose

8:01

tariffs. Theoretically, the powers that are would be

8:05

worked here in this case. We have the separate branch,

8:09

which is the judicial branch, which rules and says,

8:11

no, the president can't do that,

8:12

which is theoretically what's supposed to happen.

8:15

Collection for those tariffs stops on February 24th.

8:18

On March 6th, the CBP reports that 53 million import entries were subject

8:25

to these tariffs, these duties from more than 330,000 importers.

8:30

So on April twentieth, just c a month later after the March date,

8:34

it opens the first phase of a refund portal that it calls CAPE.

8:39

And CAPE serves importers of record,

8:42

those exact same people who are on that list.

8:44

There's no box for I bought the head shrimmer then.

8:47

No, there's no box for that. It's basically just splitting rent with

8:50

a roommate when only the roommate is the one on the lease.

8:54

You paid half every month. When you both move out,

8:57

the landlord sends the security deposit to the name on the lease.

9:00

And whether you see any of it is really up to the quality of your roommate.

9:04

If you were my roommate, I know you'd give it back to me.

9:06

But in this case, they don't necessarily have to.

9:08

Right. And if they just put down a down payment on a boat,

9:11

you can probably guess what's gonna happen with the refund.

9:13

No nobody would nobody would have a problem with that except the guy who'd

9:16

been paying rent. The the roommate is is having a great quarter in this scenario,

9:20

right? Because here is what actually happens on the company's ledger sheet,

9:25

the actual books. A refund like this comes in as income,

9:28

which means that profit actually goes up.

9:31

At these companies, bonuses essentially get calculated off of profit.

9:34

Securities experts told ProPublica that Stanley Blackendecker's refund looked like

9:40

it was lifting its profits, right?

9:42

So, and profit is an input to the company's bonus formulas.

9:46

The formula has no line for where the money came from,

9:48

like a dollar from selling a drill,

9:50

or a dollar from the treasury,

9:52

or a dollar from an income tax refund.

9:55

Basically, it just looks identical to the bean counters.

9:58

And here's how TJX booked it.

10:01

According to its filings and reportings in WWD,

10:05

the retail trade paper, TJX estimates it paid about $490 million in IEPA

10:12

tariffs. So far, it's gotten about $331 million of that back.

10:16

It accrued $112 million for year-end incentive pay and discretionary bonuses.

10:22

Accrude is doing a lot of the work here because it means it recorded the cost

10:26

now for money that it intends to pay out later.

10:30

The other $219 million went into pre-tax profit for the second quarter

10:34

of its fiscal 2027.

10:36

And that's discretionary, right?

10:37

So anybody or somebody gets to decide what happens to it.

10:40

Who gets it?

10:41

Exactly.

10:41

There's nothing stopping somebody going from saying,

10:43

hey, look, this actually didn't come in this way.

10:45

Let's actually put it back to our customers and give them to them

10:48

as a bonus. But they all have to show year over year uh return on investment

10:53

and and year over year profit growth within each company,

10:57

and they can also give themselves a piece of that bonus.

11:01

American Eagle in September filed what's called an eight K with the SEC.

11:06

It's a form that a company files when something happens,

11:09

essentially that the investors of that company need to know about right away.

11:13

It's like an emergency beacon.

11:15

$196 million in tariff refunds,

11:18

including interest. So $35 million in extra incentive compensation were tied

11:24

to those refunds. Net boost to operating incomes,

11:27

about $161 million, and a cushionet,

11:30

the tightless people, get $45 million back.

11:33

And

11:33

12 million set aside for bonuses,

11:35

and the company just declined to answer ProPublica's questions.

11:38

We didn't, we didn't contact them.

11:40

We figured they wouldn't respond to us either.

11:42

So who sits on the receiving end of these mathematical formulas?

11:47

Well, at Stanley Black and Decker,

11:49

Donald Allen Jr. was the CEO when the price hikes actually went through.

11:53

He's executive chairman now, right?

11:56

So his 2025 base salary was 135 million dollars.

12:00

And his target bonus was raised to a hundred and sixty percent of his salary.

12:05

I don't even know, these numbers don't even make sense,

12:07

as a real human being. I'm like,

12:08

can you imagine if your your boss calls you and goes,

12:12

Hey, we had a good year this year,

12:13

you're gonna get a hundred and sixty percent of your salary back as your annual

12:16

bonus. Now these people live in a completely different price range

12:20

and you know, salary target from the rest of us will,

12:23

wouldn't you say?

12:23

I would.

12:24

So this target bonus that is what an executive gets if the company hits

12:29

its goals, written as a percentage of salary.

12:32

The man who took over as CEO on October 1st,

12:34

2025, Christopher Nelson, gets a $1.3 million base salary.

12:39

So he's making slightly less than the old guy,

12:41

this, but gets the same 160% target bonus and a target of 10.345 million in stock

12:47

awards for 2026, which means

12:50

That his bonus alone comes to $2.08 million.

12:54

If the company hits its numbers.

12:56

And the refund raises the profit,

12:58

those numbers get measured against.

12:59

So your your baseline here is rising.

13:02

And so do his bonuses.

13:05

I think we're so so

13:05

Now

13:05

far we're up to triple dipping.

13:07

I don't know how much further it goes,

13:08

but

13:08

Right. if all you gotta do is change change C CEOs a couple times and

13:12

we get to claw way more of that money back.

13:13

Over at TJX, the the CEO is Ernie Herman.

13:17

The AFL CIO, which is the Federation of Labor Unions,

13:20

we've talked about them before,

13:22

tracks executive pay in a database called Paywatch.

13:25

it puts Herman's total pay for fiscal 2025

13:28

at $23,482,528.

13:34

That is one thousand five hundred and sixty-five times what the median TJ Maxx

13:41

employee made. Keep that number in your your pocket here because we'll we'll pull

13:45

that back a little bit later.

13:47

Meanwhile, before anybody knew whether there would be refunds on the tariffs,

13:50

the claims already had a price on them.

13:52

In July 2025, that's seven months before the Supreme Court ruled on the learning

13:56

resources case. Cantor Fitzgerald was reported to be buying the rights to tariff

14:00

refunds at twenty to thirty cents on the dollar.

14:03

So now there's a derivatives market on tariff refunds.

14:06

Yeah, it's it's like pork pig ears.

14:06

Cantor's the Wall Street firm.

14:08

Yeah, right. Cantor is the Wall Street firm Howard Ludnick ran before he became,

14:13

guess what?

14:13

Commerce Secretary.

14:14

Commerce Secretary.

14:15

By then the company was ruled by his,

14:17

or sorry, ruled ruled or run, however you want to put it,

14:20

by his sons. Brandon Lutnick is the chairman.

14:23

Per the Washington Times, Cantor offered importers two million to three million

14:26

dollars for every 10 million in duties they paid.

14:29

And Cantor says he never executed any any trades with Cantor on that.

14:32

All right. So let's let's look at that,

14:34

what that looks like on the streets,

14:35

right? You are a person who is importing goods from Mexico,

14:39

Canada, China, the biggest three there,

14:42

right? And you paid $10 million in tariffs.

14:45

And a firm run by the sons of a sitting cabinet secretary in the administration

14:51

that turned these tariffs on offers you two or three million now for whatever

14:57

you'd get back at the tariffs lose in court.

14:59

Great deal for the buyer if the buyer thinks the tariffs are going to lose.

15:02

But I guess the wor what I wonder is if the Commerce Secretary's kids are offering

15:06

you this deal, they must know that the tariffs are going to be paid back.

15:09

So that should have been a little bit of a red flag there.

15:11

Theoretically, they shouldn't know,

15:13

but we

15:15

Right.

15:16

have a long track record now to to prove that they probably did.

15:20

Cantor's position is that no trades actually like happened.

15:24

Nothing really occurred, and nothing we found,

15:27

you know, through our research and various other means says that there were

15:31

any trades that actually went through.

15:32

But here's what did happen on paper:

15:35

an investor named Thomas.

15:37

Brazial at a firm called 117 Partners or 117 Partners,

15:42

I'm not sure, bought $925,000 in refund claims with its own money,

15:48

betting that the tariffs would get struck down.

15:50

So American Eagles' own SEC filing says it sold some of its refund claims

15:55

in the prior fiscal year to a buyer that it will not name and doesn't really have

16:00

to.

16:00

And recorded $45 million in expenses on that deal.

16:04

Which and law firms are also filing refund claims for importers on contingency.

16:09

One of those is McCune Law Group.

16:11

They have a 20% fee as an example.

16:14

So by the time that Customs and Border Protection opened that online portal,

16:20

there was an actual whole market.

16:22

This is like couchy for tariffs at this point,

16:25

Mm-hmm.

16:25

right?

16:25

With investor money.

16:27

Which is Wall Street money, lawyers working for a cut.

16:30

Every single one of them had a route to the refund.

16:33

Or Rothschild, the guy we talked about earlier.

16:36

Also with a name like Or, and it's just O R,

16:39

not even O R E, not

16:40

Right.

16:40

O A R, just Or Rothschild. He he should be the perfect attorney,

16:45

because then he could just add on to anybody else's attorney firm and then just

16:49

be or Rothschild, who basically bought the hedge trimmer.

16:52

Has

16:53

A lawsuit currently in Connecticut.

16:55

Okay, let's talk about the company side because some of it's real and we should

16:59

give it credit where credit is due.

17:00

Okay, fine, if I have to. So I guess the strongest piece of this it's legal,

17:06

all of it. Like CVP doesn't actually put restrictions on how importers

17:09

use the refunds. If the company paid the duty,

17:12

and then the duty was later found to be illegal,

17:15

and the government sends the duty back to whoever paid it,

17:18

also the middle schooler and me keeps saying duty.

17:21

Um I I

17:22

I gonna say there's a lot of dirty

17:23

going on around here.

17:24

it's

17:24

a lot of duty. I am gonna go with tariff,

17:27

I think. just to avoid so much duty.

17:30

I don't want to step into anything.

17:31

Anyway, if they send it who it back to whoever actually paid it,

17:35

right? So N Nick Guest, who is an accounting professor at Cornell,

17:39

told the same people from PoPublica,

17:41

which is where we source the majority of the research from,

17:45

uh, the argument for refund-based bonuses could basically go both ways.

17:49

And legal analysts quoted in the Hartford Business Journal and CT Mirror.

17:54

doubt the consumer lawsuits are actually going to to actually succeed,

17:58

but nothing in the in the record says any of these companies broke a law.

18:02

I mean, there's just no law here that was broken.

18:05

Right, which is the absence of the law may be the problem.

18:08

Yes. And a as is a lot of a lot of what we're dealing with nowadays.

18:12

And this administration seems to be really good at finding those gigantic loopholes

18:17

and then exploiting them to the end of their abilities without ever closing them.

18:21

So we'll

18:21

Right.

18:22

get there. the the second part of this,

18:23

I guess, is the the one that has actual economic background behind it.

18:28

The estimates of how much of that tariff costs ends up on

18:33

consumers, right? And they're all over the United States.

18:37

The the New York Fed, the which is the regional branch of the Federal Reserve,

18:40

estimated consumers had about 26% of those costs.

18:44

So researchers at Harvard Business School put it around 43%.

18:48

And then Senator Elizabeth Warren,

18:50

one of our favorites here on the show,

18:53

has cited n ninety-five percent.

18:55

So I you know, it's it's kind of all over the

18:56

Sounds accurate.

18:57

Yeah, it's it's all over the map and on exactly how much was actually paid

19:02

by consumers. But whatever consumers didn't pay essentially got eaten

19:07

up somewhere along the supply chain.

19:09

And a lot of it by the companies themselves.

19:11

So the company's case basically is this we absorbed most of this,

19:15

whether it be fuel costs or extra pay for overtime work or whatever.

19:20

Basically, they say it came out of our margins.

19:22

And this refund essentially replaces money that we lost and otherwise would have

19:26

had had the tariffs not

19:27

But it came out of the margins for the company.

19:29

It didn't come out of the CEO's pocket.

19:31

It's not that I'm aware. but I'll I'll give them that to some extent.

19:34

Let's you if T J Max eight three quarters of the tariff,

19:37

then the refund on that part I guess is theirs,

19:39

right? Just refilling that coffer.

19:41

I guess a little bit. if you run TJX's number through the lowest estimate,

19:46

TJ X said it paid about four hundred and ninety million dollars in these tariffs.

19:51

so say T J Max Shoppers paid the same share that the New York Fed estimated

19:57

across the whole economy, which is twenty six percent.

20:00

That's an assumption and

20:01

Like I said earlier, TJ Maxx hasn't actually published its own figure.

20:04

26% of $490 million is about $127 million.

20:08

The bonus pool alone is $112 million.

20:12

So on the friendliest estimate that we have available to us,

20:16

the people who actually bought the products share is bigger than the bonus

20:21

pool.

20:22

And what if we run it at Harvard's forty three percent number?

20:24

It's about 211 million, which is within a few million of the 219 million that TJMX

20:31

added to its profits. So then there's Stanley,

20:34

Black, and Decker, and the whole we aid it defense runs straight into its own mail.

20:39

In November 2024, it told customers that tariffs would require price increases.

20:43

And in April, it raised prices,

20:46

high single digits, and planned more for the fourth quarter.

20:49

Company that sent customers a notice saying they'd be paying for the tariff

20:53

has a tough time claiming afterwards that it paid the tariff by itself.

20:56

at least on the surface, wouldn't you agree?

20:58

I would. it's kinda weird to send a letter to your clients.

21:01

It's like a a cease and desist or an empty threat letter.

21:03

hey, we're gonna we're gonna pay make you pay for these tariffs.

21:05

I don't know what that was supposed to make sales,

21:08

make people buy things before the tariffs went into effect or something.

21:10

Maybe it was like a genius

21:11

I

21:11

marketing campaign.

21:12

I thought I saw a lot of that.

21:13

to be fair, I I saw a lot of that.

21:15

get it before the tariffs increase the price on it.

21:18

Yeah. So maybe that's what this all is.

21:21

anyway, the third piece of our our company side of things is TJ Maxx's.

21:25

And I'll take their side on this for the sake of discussion.

21:28

this quote, eligible associates globally could mean store workers.

21:32

If an assistant manager at Marshalls gets a bonus out of this,

21:35

I'm not mad at the assistant manager for getting something.

21:38

I mean, they probably don't make a living wage as it is,

21:39

so

21:40

Yeah, and the the the person that's working in the cash register,

21:43

it's not their fault. if they get a bonus,

21:45

that actually might be a reasonable use case for the bonuses.

21:48

But look at what that that whole like that whole ilk kind of covers,

21:53

right? It runs from the CEO to the person stocking throw pillows at at home goods,

21:58

and a company that pays its CEO one thousand five hundred and sixty-five times

22:03

what its median worker makes.

22:05

That split could be, it could be anything,

22:06

could be 99.1. TJ Maxx hasn't really said where in that range the money goes.

22:11

And until it actually does, the title of this episode technically overstates what

22:16

we can really prove about TJ Maxx.

22:18

The fourth piece of that is that TJ Maxx says it's gonna invest the refunds

22:22

in sharper value.

22:24

Sharper values. That's a corporate term if I've ever heard one.

22:27

It's kind of like sharper image.

22:29

way too expensive for things that shouldn't cost that much.

22:32

But as anybody as far as anybody can can actually tell,

22:36

that means that the same jacket or same throw pillow might be a little cheaper

22:41

at some point by an amount that we're not gonna disclose.

22:45

they're sharpening the knives for their supplier suppliers.

22:47

That's what they mean by sharper values.

22:49

Possibly.

22:50

Got it.

22:50

Now, some companies say they're doing the the price thing for real.

22:54

according to courts, Walmart got a about two point nine billion dollar buyback

23:01

and says that it's it's rolling back prices on eleven thousand items,

23:05

which might be some of the the beef rollback on prices that we've seen in them

23:10

negotiate with Donald Trump about.

23:11

It might be, you know, other things.

23:14

Burlington can't

23:15

I the got about $55 million, right?

23:18

And says none of it's going to bonuses,

23:19

zero. Target, Costco, uh, ELF Beauty and Tractor Supply have committed

23:26

to lowering prices, right? I I'm I mean,

23:30

account me skeptical, but if you measure

23:32

Right.

23:32

that against at least the nine bonus payers,

23:35

it they might

23:36

Yeah.

23:36

be a minority in the companies actually getting refunds.

23:39

Yeah, by contrast they look pretty good.

23:41

and Burlington is basically T J Maxx's direct competitor.

23:44

same off price clothes and home goods,

23:46

same kind of tariffs and it says zero into the bonus pool.

23:49

So that's that's kudos to them.

23:51

Yeah. And uh, that was a choice that all of those other nine companies could have

23:56

made as well, right? I I mean,

23:57

the problem with the rest of the list is the word pricing.

24:01

Common Dreams reported this week that the companies promising to return refunds

24:06

through pricing have been perhaps deliberately vague about I guess what that

24:11

means. Walmart's rollbacks, I mean,

24:13

some of them are real. Like you you can actually

24:15

Go and see the we actually have a a listener of our show who tried creating

24:20

a YouTube channel to go between different Walmarts and and constantly compare

24:24

prices. And for that he got kicked off of YouTube.

24:27

But check for yourself, you know,

24:28

you might be able to to to look at the difference in prices.

24:31

Supposedly beef is lower, supposedly eggs are lower,

24:34

things like that. I mean, when I go to Walmart,

24:36

I I have to pay attention to those.

24:38

I'm trying to use the great.

24:40

uh great value and what's what's their new one that I really like it's something it's

24:44

like Good and Gather.

24:44

Greater value.

24:45

No, I wish that'd be nice. It's gosh,

24:48

what is it? It was I don't know.

24:50

It's like they're they're supposedly more premium line and they it it's kind of like

24:56

Good and Gather. I think it's better and the best or I don't know.

24:59

Who cares? Anyway, I I mean the the point I'm trying to make I think is that

25:03

Perhaps they are actually cutting the real prices.

25:07

And maybe they're gonna pass those down to people.

25:09

But after all that, the the part that sticks out to me the most is the fact that

25:12

all this is legal, none of this is against the law.

25:15

you can you can bill customers whatever you want.

25:17

To me, this would be the equivalent of price gouging and then being caught doing

25:21

it, and you pay the fine to the government instead of paying back the customers.

25:25

wait, that's how that works too.

25:27

So, the the part I guess that comes down to it is the consumer share is the part

25:31

that they mention in vagities and put them in parentheses and things like that.

25:36

But and maybe the the companies did actually absorb some money.

25:41

but if any of these companies take this money and use it for bonuses,

25:47

I think that that's something that we really need to pay attention to,

25:49

right? And and

25:50

Even if it's at the the low estimate of what what shoppers actually paid,

25:54

if they paid anything like the the average share,

25:58

I think that that would probably work out for most people,

26:00

but in most cases it doesn't.

26:02

True.

26:02

All right, let's go back to Mr.

26:04

O. R. Rothschild for a minute here because he's about as well set up as a shopper

26:08

can be. Uh he has has the job background.

26:11

He has the company's own letter saying tariffs would mean higher prices.

26:14

He has lawyers. He's one of at least two suits filed against Stanley Black

26:18

and Decker in Connecticut, and legal analysts still doubt those suits will

26:21

succeed.

26:22

Yeah, I think it's because his case is standing in opposition to the the refund

26:27

process, right? That says the money belongs to the importer with no conditions

26:31

attached. There's not a little asterisk or small print or anything.

26:33

Rothschild I mean

26:35

doesn't have really a claim on the form.

26:37

The the the C V P has a form entry number there and he's a corporate executive

26:43

and it really doesn't help him.

26:45

So I guess what decides it is whose name is on the customs form.

26:48

And put that next to Thomas Brazielle,

26:51

right? Who spent nine hundred and twenty five thousand buying up the refund claims

26:55

and and he owns a route to the money.

26:57

So he might actually get paid.

26:58

So

26:59

Rothschild who only spent his money on the the snowblower or the wrench or the hedge

27:04

trimmer or whatever. All he owns at this point is a lawsuit with a a prayer

27:08

at the outcome.

27:09

he's the best case scenario for that group.

27:12

but I do think it's interesting that,

27:13

you know, they can assign the the right the refund rights to someone else,

27:17

like who buys it. Basically he went to them and bought their right to claim

27:20

the refund. But they can't track what has gone and what's been passed along

27:25

to the customer. which is kind of kind of a weird dynamic,

27:28

I guess. But anyway, for TJ Maxx shoppers,

27:30

there's no lawsuit in anything we found.

27:32

they they haven't done anything,

27:33

they violated any laws. proof public is reporting and the suits on file

27:37

are all about Stanley Black and Decker,

27:39

given that they said, what they were doing with the terrorists and then never paid

27:43

back. the person who paid it a marshal's register doesn't appear in this story

27:46

anywhere except his revenue on TJ Maxx's bottom line.

27:49

Yeah, there's there's a bunch of T J Maxxes here.

27:51

I've never been in one, have you?

27:52

yes, I I unfortunately have. my s my wife

27:54

to Burlington.

27:55

is a always a fan. but you know,

27:58

there's there's some there's a bunch of North Carolina and Texas and everywhere

28:01

else it seems like.

28:02

All the blue states. Say

28:03

Hey, what do you know?

28:04

it's yeah, right. I mean, it's the same jacket,

28:06

right? It's the same, the same tax,

28:09

it's the same price bump on no matter what the product was.

28:12

And the and the shopper in the TJ Maxx and in the Marshalls,

28:15

they have the same number of ways to get it back,

28:17

which right now is currently zero.

28:19

It's just a hope and a prayer and that your roommate's not an asshole.

28:22

You got Warren and Booker and and Welch,

28:24

those the senators up there estimated that these tariffs

28:28

cost the average family about $1,700.

28:30

Now that's the the estimate, right?

28:32

And the the consumer share fight from a a a few minutes ago applies to the same

28:37

concept, right? Even if your number is half that and you've only paid,

28:40

$14 or what's half of $1,700? $800,

28:44

$750, $850. Yeah. I

28:44

eight fifty, yeah, I think. Yeah.

28:47

knew it was between there. Anyway,

28:49

uh, even if your numbers are half that,

28:50

right? There's no, there's no like

28:52

Claim form. There's no refund.

28:54

There's no place you can sell to Cantor for 20 bucks to to see whether

28:59

or not you you get your 1700 back,

29:02

right?

29:02

Right. So let's say you're a listener and you want to do the the obvious move

29:06

of figuring out if you got a refund or if the store you shop at got a refund

29:09

and how much of it went to the bonuses for their executives.

29:12

the people unfortunately who don't have to tell you are the private importers among

29:15

those three hundred and thirty thousand who don't file anything in public.

29:18

you know, those are those can be lots of different types of parties that that

29:21

receive the goods and make the tariff payments.

29:24

And a lot of times they're just pass through parties.

29:24

the administration.

29:26

Yeah, exactly.

29:27

the administration turned down ProPublica's record records request

29:30

on the refunds. and so then of course TJ Maxx says it can't say how it's $110

29:36

million splits until the final fiscal year ends.

29:39

So once they get all their their their numbers together at the end of the year,

29:42

presumably they'll they'll go back and add it in a footnote to some earlier report.

29:46

m But

29:48

So really the only you know outlook that

29:50

anybody has in this is your your S the SEC filing.

29:54

So SEC filings are typically written for investors.

29:57

Normally they get leaked, or you know,

29:59

institutional investor will have access to those PDFs that they send out.

30:03

It it just told investors that TJ Mox Max's profit went up 219 million dollars,

30:09

right? And nobody's required to write.

30:11

The version for the customer that goes,

30:13

hey, just so your your costs and your prices went up by $1,700 this year.

30:19

There's a a line in in ProPublica's article and writing about this from

30:23

Gregory Germain. He called executive bonuses probably the least just

30:28

way to use this money because it was the government mistake.

30:32

I mean, it's what it was. It was a mistake.

30:34

It illegally used power.

30:36

That produced the refund in the first place,

30:38

right? And when you walk through what that means,

30:41

the government imposed a tax that had no authority to actually put

30:45

on to the people. The companies took on the job of tax collector and collected

30:50

that tax from you. And some of them told you,

30:53

you know, in a letter or an email,

30:54

or you might have gotten a uh postcard in your post office box.

30:58

But the government admits that the mistake,

31:00

right? Sends the money back to the companies.

31:02

And the nine of that that we know at least,

31:04

part of it came in bonus pay.

31:06

And the refunds already out the door are past the one hundred billion dollar mark.

31:11

So whatever happens with the FTC or the lawsuits,

31:14

that money's been paid to the names in the form.

31:16

Yeah. So if you go back to the November twenty twenty four letter from Stanley

31:21

Blackendecker telling customers that,

31:23

you know, tariffs would increase the prices.

31:25

For pricing, the company treated you as a person paying the tariff.

31:29

Now for the refund, customs law treats the company as the one who paid.

31:33

And both are true right now at the same time,

31:36

right? And the company just collects under both.

31:38

So the reason who gets the refund is the hard question at all is because

31:41

the law decides who paid a tax and whose name is on the entry form.

31:45

And then lets the same party build the tax into every price it charges.

31:50

Somebody wrote that rule somewhere,

31:51

right? CBP built its refund portal around the rule that exists.

31:57

When you know, this these are the opportunities I feel like where they say,

32:00

well,

32:00

I believe in the letter of the law or I believe in the rule of law and there

32:04

was no rule around this, so there is no law.

32:07

but it's been it's been the rule under under presidents of of both parties

32:10

at this point, with Trump one and Biden and Trump two now.

32:15

So that was a choice somebody made and the bonus formulas are the same kind

32:18

of choice. I mean you have a compensation committee on the co on a typical company's

32:22

board writes those formulas and decides what counts as profit for bonus purposes.

32:26

And at these particular companies we've identified the refunds apparently counted.

32:30

So

32:30

Yeah. the fixes people are actually talking about and you know,

32:35

who who each each formula ends up costing a different person a different thing.

32:40

You have seven Senate Democrats that want the FC FTC to investigate under

32:44

the FTC Act, which bans deceptive or unfair practices.

32:48

So if the FTC decided that raising prices over tariffs and then keeping the refunds

32:52

was deceptive, that would

32:54

cost the company's actual money.

32:56

The person who'd have to act on it though is Andrew Ferguson,

33:00

the FTC chairman in this current administration.

33:02

So the same administration that actually imposed the tariffs and denied

33:06

ProPublica's records requests.

33:08

Then there's Warren and Booker and and Welch who actually called this for what

33:12

it actually is, which is a theft on the middle class.

33:15

And they demanded a plan to refund consumers and small businesses directly.

33:19

I mean that that's

33:20

To me, what also sounds like the obvious fix,

33:23

right? If you run it through the test,

33:25

where does the money come from?

33:27

If the Treasury cuts checks to families while TJ Maxx and Stanley Black and Deck

33:31

and Decker keep their refunds,

33:33

the public pays for this illegal tariff twice.

33:36

Once at the register and then once out of the federal budget,

33:39

which still comes out of our pocket one way or another another,

33:41

right? And the companies come out fine.

33:43

They they come out smelling like a rose,

33:45

honestly. Nothing in in any of this really

33:48

has a say in or even the senators would say who who would actually pay for it.

33:53

And I think a lot of times the the through pricing promises cost the companies

33:57

whatever the companies decide.

33:59

And you can't really check them on it.

34:01

Two things in this record though that would actually cost somebody at

34:04

the top is is refunds that come with a condition attached like passing them

34:08

through to customers before the money counts as profit or clawing back bonuses.

34:12

that were paid out of refund money,

34:14

either one would actually need somebody to write it.

34:17

Congress or the an administration willing to at least try it with C V P and and with

34:22

more than a hundred billion dollars of this already paid out,

34:25

a lot of that money has left the building before anybody in Washington has written

34:29

either one.

34:29

And regarding the parties, I mean the record is pretty lopsided here.

34:33

The tariffs were Trump's. We know that,

34:36

that's clear. The record's denial was his administration's the CBP.

34:40

The firm reportedly pricing refund claims was run by his Commerce Secretary Sons,

34:45

though Cantor denies that any trades took place.

34:47

Yeah, the the D Democrats' response so far is strongly written letters,

34:51

which is, you know, kind of kind of what got us here in the first place.

34:55

you know, a a letter to the F FTC really costs the CEO nothing.

34:59

I mean, the importer of record rule that sends the check to the company survived

35:04

every single administration before this one,

35:06

and nobody in this fight's really introduced any sort of legislation that

35:09

changes it. so the question is pretty specific,

35:12

and I think.

35:13

It really comes into the incoming Congress,

35:16

right? Who writes these conditions and can it pass before the next round of money

35:20

goes out? Will it get vetoed? Who knows?

35:22

Who knows? So if somebody worked brings up tariffs this week or if they read

35:26

the Pro Public article, what's the two sentence version?

35:28

I don't know, point at the podcast.

35:30

You you paid the tariffs, right?

35:32

At the register. the Stanley Black and Decker literally mailed a peop people

35:36

a letter saying that you were gonna pay these tariffs.

35:39

And then when the Supreme Court said the tariffs were illegal,

35:42

the refund went to whose ever name was on the customs form.

35:45

And TJ Maxx was a about a third of it.

35:48

Hundred and twelve million out of three hundred and thirty one million gets

35:51

set aside for bonuses. You're welcome.

35:53

After being added to profit, which is sick.

35:55

Mm-hmm.

35:56

And if somebody wants a third sentence,

35:58

Burlington got a refund too and says none of it went to bonuses.

36:00

So there's a choice that was made here.

36:02

Yeah. The thing we're really watching now is the split.

36:05

TJ Maxx says it can't break out who gets the hundred and twelve million until

36:08

its fiscal year is over. And when that number shows up,

36:11

we'll know whether eligible associates globally means the people like folding

36:15

sweaters and doing the work or just the people at the top with a fifteen

36:19

sixty-five to one pay ratio.

36:22

And whether the FTC does anything with those letters.

36:24

But I think if they had asked me,

36:26

I would have told them to include a rebate form on all their their receipts for items

36:30

that had tariffs attached to them.

36:31

'Cause those rebates never get paid back,

36:33

right? So they could then just use the money to to pay the executives.

36:36

I've never had one of those re rebates ever

36:37

Even better, it comes as a gift card.

36:38

actually produce anything. So yeah.

36:40

Or gift card to a non existent company.

36:42

Exactly. And then then, you know,

36:45

a monthly maintenance fee on the gift card balance.

36:47

And anyway, i everything in this episode thirteen CDs for a penny.

36:47

Right. And then you s they sign you up for Columbia House,

36:50

start getting uh tapes, audio cassettes,

36:53

yeah.

36:53

Everybody in this everything in this episode came from public reporting

36:56

and public filings, pro publica,

36:58

the SEC filings, the Hartford Business Journal,

37:00

CT Mirror Courts, the Senators own letters,

37:03

as well as the Library of Congress that records those.

37:05

So you can read every bit of this for yourself.

37:07

Remember to do your duty. And if you if you have duty done to you,

37:11

then I don't know where that's going.

37:12

Okay. You can find us at FOF.foundation

37:13

Don't duty there, booty.

37:15

and on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

37:18

If you get a story or a correction,

37:19

we'd love to hear from you. Email us at the overlap at FOF.foundation.

37:23

And if you got something out of this,

37:25

give us a five star rating. It helps people find the show.

37:28

Share it far and wide. If you see us somewhere on social media,

37:30

especially Blue Sky or Mastodon,

37:33

give us a follow and and share us there.

37:35

And all those things would be kind things to do.

37:38

And we always say, be kind to each other.

37:39

Help out where you can.

37:41

And we always say at the end, bye.

37:42

Bye.